Given the actual issues facing our nation, to even be reminded that presidential elections in this country have come down to this philosophical tail-chase makes me want to move to Canada, or some other place where folks outscore us on those achievement tests on which we keep falling so far behind.
NO AMERICAN PRESIDENT has ever had an abortion and given the candidates we have now, that will be true for at least another 4 years so his stance on the issue is moot. Irrelevant. Not likely to come up in the next Iraq summit. Not likely to come up in the next bailout hearing. Not likely to come up in the next energy policy development session. Not likely to come up in the next "what will replace our auto industry" discussion. Not likely to come up in the N. Korea... well you get the point.
Look people, I think we can all agree that to even be faced with the choice of whether or not to have an abortion means you're in a horrible situation. For it to be the favorable choice, it's probably even worse. No one WANTS to have an abortion. No one sets out to be in that position. But there ARE circumstances under which... no, forget that. Let's not even talk about it. It's not the point. The point is, it's NOT presidential selection material by at least 10 or 1000 more pressing, day to day national issues. This is indisputable for many, many reasons, but I'll list just a few.
1) It doesn't matter. Given Bush's track record in his first term, I have to assume that a large number of folks voted for him the second time purely on the abortion issue. He's probably the most outspoken anti-abortion candidate we've had in a long time and yet what has he accomplished for those folks in return for that vote? Nada. Zip. No change whatsoever. So what did that pro-life vote get us? (here you should list: the war, the economic crisis, the failed response to one national disaster after another, the largest deficit in our history, the largest sale of that debt to foreign nations ever)
2) Economic policy has a far greater impact on the number of abortions than a president's personal views. Check back through CBO and Catholic Charities stats... the numbers of abortions go down when social program spending goes up. (note: this includes jobs programs as well as flat out welfare, so we're not just talking handouts and note that on this issue in particular, jobs programs have a far more dramatic effect than trickle down theories, but that's only based on the stats - I'm no economist) I'll venture a guess that our current economic situation will end up having an adverse effect on Bush's ability to curtail abortions. (it almost sounds ridiculous to say that, doesn't it? "Bush's ability to curtail abortion..." You're right, it's not part of the job description. It's not up to him. That's another reason why it's a stupid factor to consider anywhere near the top of the list.)
3) A true sign of leadership is one's ability to put one's personal views aside and consider the needs of all first. Now I obviously feel that this means stopping the abortion discussion before it starts and tackling the national issues that are the most pressing. You don't have to agree with me on that, but you have to admit, the inverse of what I'm saying here is that leadership = selfishness. I know it's a fallacy to try to prove a point by disproving it's inverse, but given the number of folks who believe Palin is a legitimate candidate to be president, I figured I'd offer an easy to follow, Limbaugh-esque argument. Besides, W has proven what happens when you get the inverse, so I don't really have to rely on the fallacy.
4) see the last two sentences in #2
5) Often, the selection based on this particular non-criterion is deeply religious based. That's fine for an individual, but don't try to impose that irrational motivation on the rest of us. Believe or not, there are folks in the world (religious and otherwise, pro-life and otherwise) who like to apply a little bit of rationality to their important decisions. I'm not saying faith should never play a part in an individual's decision, but faith, by definition is irrational, so don't try to invoke it as part of a rational argument when attempting to convince others. If you want religion to play a greater role in your government, move to southwest Asia. They're big on that kind of thing. We have a constitution designed to make rationality the basis of our laws. It's reasonable to discuss the issue in legal terms, compare it to murder, etc. but don't just tell me it's wrong, especially when it will save the life of an underage rape victim sentenced to death by an ectopic pregnancy she had no say in creating.
That's enough of that. I wanted to shed light on some of the other crazy-assed things I've heard from McPalin backers:
"Clinton sold us out to China" (not sure what the basis of this one is, but I know our debt became real easy for China to buy AFTER Bush spent the last of Clinton's surplus and began spending us into the place where we are now. We're cheaper and easier to buy today than we've ever been and it's true... China's doing the buying, but Clinton ain't at the helm.)
"I like her (Palin) she seems real." (I agree... a real girl next door... a real Miss Alaska... a real totally unqualified to lead the country neighbor. I'd probably like her too, but not as the leader of the free world. Doesn't anyone remember where the old "I'd rather have a beer with that one" standard got us?)
"Obama's an Arab/Muslim" I hope Colin Powell put both of the reasons why this is idiotic to rest: 1. He's not. 2. So what if he were? Saying all Muslims/Arabs are terrorists is as crazy as saying all Christians are David Koresh or Jim Jones or Rev. Wright Carter was a Baptist. Kennedy was Catholic. If this argument holds any weight, it's an argument in favor of electing an atheist. After all, if A religion can be wrong, then ALL religions can be wrong. Ironically, atheism is probably the only "spiritual" denomination that CAN'T get elected in this dumbass country.
"McCain's the true Christian" Not only is the idea of a religious litmus test strictly prohibited by our constitution, but this idea isn't supported by his actions. Obama is a Christian as the result of a lifetime of searching for his own spirituality, which included having observed a number of varying faiths. He asked a lot of questions and continues to search for answers. That's faith. That's a spiritual journey. That's believing in something. McCain, on the other hand, is a "Christian" by virtue of something he wrote down on a congressional bio a number of years ago. This is no secret... the church-going only seems to come out when cameras are around prior to an election. McCain all but admits to this... the news hounds have the evidence making the admission unnecessary, but those liberal bastards are keeping all this to themselves! This is actually one of the reasons I liked the pre-party-mind-melded McCain.
So anyway, yeah, consider the unborn in your vote, but only if you're Christian... that's what the signs say. I guess everyone else is free to consider where we want to be as a nation in four years.
Luth,
Out.
The weekly, OK, monthly, OK quarterly ramblings of a regular guy with a mildly liberal bent, who is sick of BOTH parties and their BS. For those of you just joining us, click on the March 2005 archive, scroll to the bottom of the posts, and read your way back up... or at least read that first one to see how this mess got started out of fear and boredom in Iraq.
Monday, October 20, 2008
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Another disappointing debate
Now that the Clintons are firmly in the Obama camp, Bill needs to give a few lessons to Obama on how to poke the bear with a smile on his face. On several occasions during this week's debate, McCain was clearly on the verge of exploding. All it would have taken was just a little stirring of his boiling pot and he would have lost it. I kept having day dreams of McCain tearing off his lapel mic, throwing it down on the desk and stomping off, but instead, Obama remained cool and calm, as always, and took the high road most of the night.
I'm torn, because this is one of the things I like most about Obama. I look forward to our nation being lead by a calm, educated, rational (for the most part) thinker who actually listens, considers, seeks input, and is clearly willing to admit he doesn't know everything before flying off and firmly declaring his next stubborn intention.
But just once I'd like to see McCain lose it and show his true colors. His temper is no secret and as long as we're deciding our next president based on ridiculously irrelevant factors, one's ability to maintain self control actually sounds pretty important. Why won't Obama just push him a little closer to that edge?
I mentioned this to a colleague the morning after the debate and he noted that Obama can't risk appearing to be "the angry black man." I hadn't thought of that, but it sure made sense once he said it. After all, look at what the media (yeah, those dirty liberals) did to Michelle! People still think she's angry and I suppose this is what scares me the most... that the "Bradley Effect," a euphemism for racist ignorance, will render the actual election a lot closer than the polling shows. The special edition of SNL tonight noted this rather succinctly when a Jesse Jackson character on "SNL News" quoted a poll saying 87% of Americans said they would, in fact, vote for a black man. The follow up question was, "Really?" and the numbers were almost a reciprocal... with only 25% saying they would. Under the cover of the voting booth curtain, I'm afraid we're still a lot more racist than we like to believe.
But back to the debate. There were so many easy pitches to hit that Obama just laid off of I almost wanted to scream. Seriously... that question about why you think your running mate is more qualified to run the country? If I were McCain, I would have asked if I could just pass on that one! Obama had the perfect opportunity to note how his own experience (which makes him seem like a seasoned old pro when compared to Palin) was a favorite topic of McCain's up until Palin was selected, but instead he simply replied with "we'll let the American voters decide."
PUHLEASE!
And how many times do we have to go over the Bill Ayers thing? If you get your news from anyone other than Hannity, you must know by now how ridiculous McPalin's claims are regarding the work Obama did on a bi-partisan committee that just happened to include Ayers as well as several noted Republicans. Why aren't the Republicans on that committee included as having run around with terrorists?
And ACORN? Apparently they're a real patriotic organization when they register Republicans, but when they register Dems, they're cheaters and liars. McCain was their keynote speaker at an immigration event in Florida in 2006 and has supported the grass roots organization fairly consistently up until very recently. Perhaps his newest backers don't like the organization made up primarily of low and middle income American citizens. The membership apparently isn't patriotic enough these days.
Then there's the Palin record that McCain spoke so much about... her tax cutting record?... that's not how most Wasilla residents who are still paying for the hockey arena that seats more people than live in the town see it. And what was that bridge going to cost taxpayers?
Which brings me to another question I've been pondering... Republicans often accuse Dems of saying "trust us to spend your money." And with that, I've often seen the point. But after the last seven years... and throughout the Reagan-Bush era, the alternative seems to be "trust our rich friends with your money and maybe some of it will make it back down to you." That too has some theoretical validity, but practice has proven over and over again (a 12 year stint for Reagan-Bush and now nearly 8 more) that it just doesn't work. Under Republicans, not only has government expanded, but it's cost more than ever. That's not technically a tax increase, but we're paying for it no matter what you call it. Over the last 7 years we've seen that the true difference between Repub and Dem economic policy is that while Dems tax and spend, Repubs just spend. The fact that all that spending will somehow have to be paid for by taxpayers will be ok as long as it's not called a tax increase.
Call it what you want - if it feels better for you, I'll pretend it's not really a tax increase - but when the American public pays off the debt this Republican administration has racked up, it's a tax... on us and our kids and their kids.
And finally, Joe the (not a) plumber. I don't care if the guy's got a license or not. What really pisses me off is the idea that a real guy and a purely hypothetical problem were all presented as actual as though Obama actually yanked the American dream from this guy who apparently didn't even take high school accounting. If a two-employee business is really clearing $250 grand a year, then they should be taxed at a ridiculous rate. The tax will teach them to hire a better accountant or give themselves better salaries (you know, expenses that reduce their profit) Every small business with half a brain knows the business itself never makes a profit, let alone $250k.
And speaking of distorted interpretations of tax plans, Parade magazine ran an article this weekend headlined "How much will you pay?" Note the last word in that headline: PAY. The most prominent text in the article was a table that actually listed how much taxpayers in each category would SAVE, not PAY. Most folks (those making less than $250k a year) make out far better under the Obama plan than under the McCain plan, but if all you read is the headline and the table, just the opposite appears to be true. Is this the kind of LIBERAL media trick folks are always talking about? Yep, for 95% of Americans and even a slightly higher percentage of small businesses, the Obama plan represents a tax cut. So if that's what you're looking for and you don't earn McCain-type money, O's your man.
I don't think I'm done quite yet, but I'm tired of this again.
Luth,
Out.
I'm torn, because this is one of the things I like most about Obama. I look forward to our nation being lead by a calm, educated, rational (for the most part) thinker who actually listens, considers, seeks input, and is clearly willing to admit he doesn't know everything before flying off and firmly declaring his next stubborn intention.
But just once I'd like to see McCain lose it and show his true colors. His temper is no secret and as long as we're deciding our next president based on ridiculously irrelevant factors, one's ability to maintain self control actually sounds pretty important. Why won't Obama just push him a little closer to that edge?
I mentioned this to a colleague the morning after the debate and he noted that Obama can't risk appearing to be "the angry black man." I hadn't thought of that, but it sure made sense once he said it. After all, look at what the media (yeah, those dirty liberals) did to Michelle! People still think she's angry and I suppose this is what scares me the most... that the "Bradley Effect," a euphemism for racist ignorance, will render the actual election a lot closer than the polling shows. The special edition of SNL tonight noted this rather succinctly when a Jesse Jackson character on "SNL News" quoted a poll saying 87% of Americans said they would, in fact, vote for a black man. The follow up question was, "Really?" and the numbers were almost a reciprocal... with only 25% saying they would. Under the cover of the voting booth curtain, I'm afraid we're still a lot more racist than we like to believe.
But back to the debate. There were so many easy pitches to hit that Obama just laid off of I almost wanted to scream. Seriously... that question about why you think your running mate is more qualified to run the country? If I were McCain, I would have asked if I could just pass on that one! Obama had the perfect opportunity to note how his own experience (which makes him seem like a seasoned old pro when compared to Palin) was a favorite topic of McCain's up until Palin was selected, but instead he simply replied with "we'll let the American voters decide."
PUHLEASE!
And how many times do we have to go over the Bill Ayers thing? If you get your news from anyone other than Hannity, you must know by now how ridiculous McPalin's claims are regarding the work Obama did on a bi-partisan committee that just happened to include Ayers as well as several noted Republicans. Why aren't the Republicans on that committee included as having run around with terrorists?
And ACORN? Apparently they're a real patriotic organization when they register Republicans, but when they register Dems, they're cheaters and liars. McCain was their keynote speaker at an immigration event in Florida in 2006 and has supported the grass roots organization fairly consistently up until very recently. Perhaps his newest backers don't like the organization made up primarily of low and middle income American citizens. The membership apparently isn't patriotic enough these days.
Then there's the Palin record that McCain spoke so much about... her tax cutting record?... that's not how most Wasilla residents who are still paying for the hockey arena that seats more people than live in the town see it. And what was that bridge going to cost taxpayers?
Which brings me to another question I've been pondering... Republicans often accuse Dems of saying "trust us to spend your money." And with that, I've often seen the point. But after the last seven years... and throughout the Reagan-Bush era, the alternative seems to be "trust our rich friends with your money and maybe some of it will make it back down to you." That too has some theoretical validity, but practice has proven over and over again (a 12 year stint for Reagan-Bush and now nearly 8 more) that it just doesn't work. Under Republicans, not only has government expanded, but it's cost more than ever. That's not technically a tax increase, but we're paying for it no matter what you call it. Over the last 7 years we've seen that the true difference between Repub and Dem economic policy is that while Dems tax and spend, Repubs just spend. The fact that all that spending will somehow have to be paid for by taxpayers will be ok as long as it's not called a tax increase.
Call it what you want - if it feels better for you, I'll pretend it's not really a tax increase - but when the American public pays off the debt this Republican administration has racked up, it's a tax... on us and our kids and their kids.
And finally, Joe the (not a) plumber. I don't care if the guy's got a license or not. What really pisses me off is the idea that a real guy and a purely hypothetical problem were all presented as actual as though Obama actually yanked the American dream from this guy who apparently didn't even take high school accounting. If a two-employee business is really clearing $250 grand a year, then they should be taxed at a ridiculous rate. The tax will teach them to hire a better accountant or give themselves better salaries (you know, expenses that reduce their profit) Every small business with half a brain knows the business itself never makes a profit, let alone $250k.
And speaking of distorted interpretations of tax plans, Parade magazine ran an article this weekend headlined "How much will you pay?" Note the last word in that headline: PAY. The most prominent text in the article was a table that actually listed how much taxpayers in each category would SAVE, not PAY. Most folks (those making less than $250k a year) make out far better under the Obama plan than under the McCain plan, but if all you read is the headline and the table, just the opposite appears to be true. Is this the kind of LIBERAL media trick folks are always talking about? Yep, for 95% of Americans and even a slightly higher percentage of small businesses, the Obama plan represents a tax cut. So if that's what you're looking for and you don't earn McCain-type money, O's your man.
I don't think I'm done quite yet, but I'm tired of this again.
Luth,
Out.
Monday, September 29, 2008
Liberals and Conservatives
I had planned for this post to be a sort of return to erudition after that last rant. Sadly, that would require more discipline (and erudition) than I have. But I will offer this endorsement of the latest fascinating TED video I've watched:
(I can't get the $#%@! link to work so paste this in your browser and smoke it: http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/
jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind.html)
I don't know if I've ever actually gotten around to sharing how wonderful this whole TED thing is on here yet... I know I've meant to on several occasions when I've vowed to try to post something more than once a month, but I don't know that I ever did it.
Anyhoo, in this particular video, psychologist Jonathan Haidt gives a scientific explanation of the difference between liberals and conservatives. And get this, there's no screaming or name calling and he explains that BOTH have morals!! I know, I know... it's crazy. Anyhoo, I can't possibly do justice to his prepared 19 minute talk so you'll just have to watch it on your own. All I will say is that it gave me immeasurable insight into my own sort of multiple personality leanings. In fact, if there's any merit to his explanation, I'm probably not alone. His most salient point (IMHO) was that while liberals might be the ones who embrace new ideas, NO new ideas can be exchanged when either side assumes groupthink and fails to acknowledge ideas from the other. It's the teaming up that makes both sides stupid! Ain't it great how we minimize this weakness during election season?!
OK, now on to the real poup.
I was entertained by the morning's speech returns from McPalin, who derided Obama for "sitting on the sidelines" rather than getting involved, like McCain, in solving our current financial crisis. What was really entertaining was when this second attempt at getting involved failed. There are a couple of points here that McPalin seems to have missed, but first I have to instill my own false logic into the picture with one little reminder. McCain, suspending his campaign, except for about a day's worth of appearances in his "rush" to DC to solve the problem, arrived shortly after what seemed like a deal had been struck. Then the deal went sour.
That's a post hoc ergo proctor hoc there... it happened after so it must have happened because of. (It's a fallacy... not really logical to assume that McCain's presence shot the deal down) I know, I know, but I had to do it. It's what people do during the campaign season!
Anyhoo, this morning, McPalin was all "I got in there and rolled up my sleeves" and he was like "Obama was all sitting on the sidelines."
But then another deal went sour and the speeches changed a little. After the news that the latest version of corporate welfare had failed, leaving us precariously teetering on the edge of financial failure, McPlain was all, "Obama and his Democrat allies are playing a dangerous game in blocking this bill... toying with hard working Americans' money by calling Paulson's bluff." See how they did that - they pulled Obama off the sidelines, put him into the game, and then blamed him. Touche... no one will see through that!
But then the news broke that it was actually House Republicans who felt the deal was a little too pro-banker (which in this case was deemed "fiscally unconservative") and McPalin was all, "oh... now what?"
I can understand their shock. House Republicans voting against making the rich richer? Since when? Isn't that what this administration is all about? Where's the executive influence on the hill? Where's the Newt when we need him to put another contract on America? Has the world shifted off its axis?
While we're on the subject, let's call this bailout plan what it is: welfare. Remember how universal health care was called "socialist" or "too expensive" and any social program, hell, taxes in general were labeled a redistribution of wealth rewarding non-producers? Now why would it be called anything different when the money flows the other way? More importantly, why are we just now realizing only this latest round of it when it's been the MO of this administration since day one... corporate tax breaks, oil royalties forgiven, CEO's hiding behind corporate law ("no individual was to blame") and avoiding prosecution while accepting their golden parachutes funded by looting the savings of their middle class investors... how are we just noticing this full-on sell out of 95% of America to the wealthiest 5%? Oh, yeah, it's because the 5% gambled with their winnings and lost!
What Bush/Paulson have proposed to fix it is the largest single tax hike in American history. They are about to tax every single man, woman and child in the country to the tune of about $2500.00. (that's 700 billion/300 million with some rounding in my favor) That doesn't sound like much, but it makes their cheesy little "economic stimulus" checks sound like a really lame idea. Never mind that about half of those folks didn't report any income, or that this is about twice the amount of actual welfare in the 2006 budget. ("Means Tested Entitlements FY 2006")
It's welfare... only it's cool when it's for the rich, even if it's only necessary because their latest gamble didn't pay off. Not one penny of this will put a lower middle class family back into their foreclosed upon home after they missed one payment. And the real real shitty part is that we HAVE to do it! It won't make life any easier for those of us who have been paying the giant corporate salaries or whose money these guys have been gambling with but since Wall Street is on the verge of missing a whole bunch of payments - though no fault of the American taxpayer or investor, as a result of that gamble, WE have to cough it up. Because if we don't we'll see exactly to whom Bush has actually sold America: China, Japan, the UAE, Saudi Arabia...
Remember all that debt that Republican economists keep telling us isn't real money? I'm thinking the folks who hold the notes for it think it's pretty real and I'm thinking they'll want to cash out when AIG gets a taste of their own medicine. So yeah, we have no choice now. We have to pump mass cash into the "level playing field of the open market." And we will, but next time around, let's not forget the high water mark of this debacle.
As of now, it's only reached a few feet into the middle class, but by McPalin's standards, that middle class extends into those households that earn $5 million a year. If you're not in that top 5% to whom this welfare is being handed, you're not safe either. Who knows how high the water will actually reach before a bailout bill is finally accepted. I'm only cocky because all I own is debt. (of course, unlike naked short sellers, my debt is in the form of a house) Either way, when it's called in, I'm a free man... homeless, but free! I don't have much to lose. And I don't expect anyone to bail me out.
It certainly calls to mind one of my favorite bumper stickers: If you're a Republican and you're not rich, you're stupid." (don't go there, Ray, there are some good Dem stickers too, but they don't fit this particular rant)
Maybe stupid is too harsh a word, but for those of us firmly in the middle class who are one illness or one downsizing away from bankruptcy, this one comes dangerously close. Do you still think only Democrats tax and spend? Do you still think government shouldn't regulate industry upon which the national economy rests? Do you still think the war in Iraq was a good way to spend our money? Do you still think abortion is the most important issue facing the nation? I only mention abortion here cuz everyone's familiar with China's stance on it. Since they own a ton of our debt, we could soon be one of them! Your last pro-life vote could result in us being subsumed by the second largest pro-choice proponents in the universe!
Back to the point: The bail out is a tax funded welfare program. The biggest of it's kind in history. We either suck it up, or we become Chinese. Once it's in place, we'll be closer to socialism than we've ever been. We've become the French. At least our flag has the right colors!
Luth,
Out
(I can't get the $#%@! link to work so paste this in your browser and smoke it: http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/
jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind.html)
I don't know if I've ever actually gotten around to sharing how wonderful this whole TED thing is on here yet... I know I've meant to on several occasions when I've vowed to try to post something more than once a month, but I don't know that I ever did it.
Anyhoo, in this particular video, psychologist Jonathan Haidt gives a scientific explanation of the difference between liberals and conservatives. And get this, there's no screaming or name calling and he explains that BOTH have morals!! I know, I know... it's crazy. Anyhoo, I can't possibly do justice to his prepared 19 minute talk so you'll just have to watch it on your own. All I will say is that it gave me immeasurable insight into my own sort of multiple personality leanings. In fact, if there's any merit to his explanation, I'm probably not alone. His most salient point (IMHO) was that while liberals might be the ones who embrace new ideas, NO new ideas can be exchanged when either side assumes groupthink and fails to acknowledge ideas from the other. It's the teaming up that makes both sides stupid! Ain't it great how we minimize this weakness during election season?!
OK, now on to the real poup.
I was entertained by the morning's speech returns from McPalin, who derided Obama for "sitting on the sidelines" rather than getting involved, like McCain, in solving our current financial crisis. What was really entertaining was when this second attempt at getting involved failed. There are a couple of points here that McPalin seems to have missed, but first I have to instill my own false logic into the picture with one little reminder. McCain, suspending his campaign, except for about a day's worth of appearances in his "rush" to DC to solve the problem, arrived shortly after what seemed like a deal had been struck. Then the deal went sour.
That's a post hoc ergo proctor hoc there... it happened after so it must have happened because of. (It's a fallacy... not really logical to assume that McCain's presence shot the deal down) I know, I know, but I had to do it. It's what people do during the campaign season!
Anyhoo, this morning, McPalin was all "I got in there and rolled up my sleeves" and he was like "Obama was all sitting on the sidelines."
But then another deal went sour and the speeches changed a little. After the news that the latest version of corporate welfare had failed, leaving us precariously teetering on the edge of financial failure, McPlain was all, "Obama and his Democrat allies are playing a dangerous game in blocking this bill... toying with hard working Americans' money by calling Paulson's bluff." See how they did that - they pulled Obama off the sidelines, put him into the game, and then blamed him. Touche... no one will see through that!
But then the news broke that it was actually House Republicans who felt the deal was a little too pro-banker (which in this case was deemed "fiscally unconservative") and McPalin was all, "oh... now what?"
I can understand their shock. House Republicans voting against making the rich richer? Since when? Isn't that what this administration is all about? Where's the executive influence on the hill? Where's the Newt when we need him to put another contract on America? Has the world shifted off its axis?
While we're on the subject, let's call this bailout plan what it is: welfare. Remember how universal health care was called "socialist" or "too expensive" and any social program, hell, taxes in general were labeled a redistribution of wealth rewarding non-producers? Now why would it be called anything different when the money flows the other way? More importantly, why are we just now realizing only this latest round of it when it's been the MO of this administration since day one... corporate tax breaks, oil royalties forgiven, CEO's hiding behind corporate law ("no individual was to blame") and avoiding prosecution while accepting their golden parachutes funded by looting the savings of their middle class investors... how are we just noticing this full-on sell out of 95% of America to the wealthiest 5%? Oh, yeah, it's because the 5% gambled with their winnings and lost!
What Bush/Paulson have proposed to fix it is the largest single tax hike in American history. They are about to tax every single man, woman and child in the country to the tune of about $2500.00. (that's 700 billion/300 million with some rounding in my favor) That doesn't sound like much, but it makes their cheesy little "economic stimulus" checks sound like a really lame idea. Never mind that about half of those folks didn't report any income, or that this is about twice the amount of actual welfare in the 2006 budget. ("Means Tested Entitlements FY 2006")
It's welfare... only it's cool when it's for the rich, even if it's only necessary because their latest gamble didn't pay off. Not one penny of this will put a lower middle class family back into their foreclosed upon home after they missed one payment. And the real real shitty part is that we HAVE to do it! It won't make life any easier for those of us who have been paying the giant corporate salaries or whose money these guys have been gambling with but since Wall Street is on the verge of missing a whole bunch of payments - though no fault of the American taxpayer or investor, as a result of that gamble, WE have to cough it up. Because if we don't we'll see exactly to whom Bush has actually sold America: China, Japan, the UAE, Saudi Arabia...
Remember all that debt that Republican economists keep telling us isn't real money? I'm thinking the folks who hold the notes for it think it's pretty real and I'm thinking they'll want to cash out when AIG gets a taste of their own medicine. So yeah, we have no choice now. We have to pump mass cash into the "level playing field of the open market." And we will, but next time around, let's not forget the high water mark of this debacle.
As of now, it's only reached a few feet into the middle class, but by McPalin's standards, that middle class extends into those households that earn $5 million a year. If you're not in that top 5% to whom this welfare is being handed, you're not safe either. Who knows how high the water will actually reach before a bailout bill is finally accepted. I'm only cocky because all I own is debt. (of course, unlike naked short sellers, my debt is in the form of a house) Either way, when it's called in, I'm a free man... homeless, but free! I don't have much to lose. And I don't expect anyone to bail me out.
It certainly calls to mind one of my favorite bumper stickers: If you're a Republican and you're not rich, you're stupid." (don't go there, Ray, there are some good Dem stickers too, but they don't fit this particular rant)
Maybe stupid is too harsh a word, but for those of us firmly in the middle class who are one illness or one downsizing away from bankruptcy, this one comes dangerously close. Do you still think only Democrats tax and spend? Do you still think government shouldn't regulate industry upon which the national economy rests? Do you still think the war in Iraq was a good way to spend our money? Do you still think abortion is the most important issue facing the nation? I only mention abortion here cuz everyone's familiar with China's stance on it. Since they own a ton of our debt, we could soon be one of them! Your last pro-life vote could result in us being subsumed by the second largest pro-choice proponents in the universe!
Back to the point: The bail out is a tax funded welfare program. The biggest of it's kind in history. We either suck it up, or we become Chinese. Once it's in place, we'll be closer to socialism than we've ever been. We've become the French. At least our flag has the right colors!
Luth,
Out
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Still only a few points difference, seriously?
I felt an urgent need I could no longer ignore for this short, sweet post. I'll warn you right from the start that it's a rant, nothing more.
First, I must repeat it once again, I used to like this McCain guy. If he remains a senator I probably will again AFTER this election is over, but COME ON. How can anyone seriously be considering voting for this guy after the last seven years, the nasty campaign, the lessons learned over a similar 12-year experiment under Reagan and Bush 41 that resulted in a triple double (inflation, interest rates and unemployment) and the initial steps toward the deregulation that dumped today's economic crisis in our laps on top of everything else right now?
Does an attractive VP who says the right things on TV REALLY wash away her career that flies in the face of those TV promises? Wasn't her selection so blatant and obvious an attempt to inject gender and age (Hillary voters) to the ticket that even the most right-leaning Repub HAS to see through it? Even long-time Repubs are asking if there wasn't someone more qualified he could have picked... some congresswoman or governor. And how does family values now include pregnant, unwed teens? Isn't that what the family values folks always told us they'd do away with? Doesn't it strike anyone else as disingenuous at best that "at least she didn't abort" has become the standard to replace "just say no?!"
Are a few TV promises that are clearly contradictory to the pair's track record really all it takes to leave us in the complacency... now downward spiral where we don't even care about the issues as long as we get the party right? Are folks so bent on their party loyalty that the BS of the campaign is all it takes to make us forget our jobs, our homes, our health care, our children's futures, our common sense?
Look. If you don't like Obama or the Democratic Party that much, then vote for Ron Paul or Ralph Nader, or just don't even vote. I never thought I'd say that, but how can you seriously consider McCain-Palin? Sure they're NOT the SAME as W, but they HAVE based their campaign on supporting his two favorite issues: the economy and the war. On those issues, they may not be the same, but they're certainly in the same camp and where has it gotten us? After choosing the candidate with whom you'd rather have a beer, can't we agree that being just like us isn't the best reason to choose the guy in the top post? Hell, if that's your criteria, then I want to be your president. I'm fun to have a beer with!
Yes, this is a challenge for someone to convince me that McCain is still the guy I thought he was as a senator who got the job done. It's the second time I've issued this challenge. If you bother to read more than the one little detail you came here to either agree with or rail against, you'd know that I'll consider just about any argument. I'll defend my position, but I'll also listen intently to and seriously weigh those of others. I've listened throughout the campaigns believing, at least at the beginning, that it would be the first in my lifetime that actually offered us two good choices as opposed to the lesser of two evils. I no longer believe that and given the lunacy of the McCain campaign, I can't believe anyone is still falling for it to the point that it's even remotely close.
Look, I'm not a Democrat. I'm an independent with a little "i" because it's not a party. I vote for the best candidate regardless of party and I've voted for more Repubs in the last 10 years than I have Dems. I'm liberal in that I expect others to consider new ideas and to bear some responsibility for the welfare of others when they can. I'm conservative when it comes to personal responsibility, including that responsibility to occasionally be my brother's keeper when I have the means and he has the need. And I really think that my fellow voters have a responsibility to give me something better than the party line to explain why this guy is still a viable presidential candidate. I really tried to find it on my own and I'm simply stunned that it just doesn't seem to be there when you strip away the party trappings and yet, the polls have it as just a few point difference. Somebody explain that to me.
Does anyone out there honestly believe McCain is backing out of the debate in order to save our economy after he worked so hard to do away with the kinds of regulation we're now considering imposing? C'mon. He's got no chance to come out of that debate with anything but lost support and he knows it. Like Obama or not, he's going to clean up... or maybe not. Maybe the debate is what I need to change my mind, but without McCain involved, I won't get the chance, so somebody's got to help me see what half of our polled voters see in this ticket. Broaden my perspective before the debate... or before McCain ducks it.
W is talking legacy still and it's time we all consider what that might actually be... first and foremost there's the war. No matter how you feel about that, the legacy of how it was sold to us and how it's gone thus far is not going to be pretty. Then there's the nationalizing of the banking industry - the closest move toward socialism we've had since the Depression all while telling us out the other side of the face that nationalized health care is a bad idea and government should keep its hands off industry. Then there's the growing divide between the top 1% of wage earners and the bottom 99% which was supposed to materialize into/trickle down by creating all kinds of economic growth but instead resulted in all kinds of foreign ownership and record unemployment. And finally there's what all of this luxury will cost us: yep the national debt! Now that's a legacy our great grandchildren can share!
Thus far, McCain has promised to shore up that legacy by augmenting it. He wants the war to continue to be the biggest drain on our economy indefinitely with no objectives to signal its success or failure or completion. He'll make up for that, apparently, by admitting that his laissez-fair economic policy for the last 26 years was wrong then borrowing even more taxpayer money to bail out the campaign contributors who benefited most from those policies and whose golden parachutes are apparently not enough to sustain them while the rest of us fall farther and farther into the hole supporting them by running their plants and building their products for paychecks that buy less and less and benefits that are all but extinct.
Does anyone out there still think that someone's stance on gay marriage or abortion means more than a rat's ass compared to the issues the next president must solve? Are those two issues and gun laws REALLY what we're voting on this year? Does a label like conservative or liberal or Dem or Repub REALLY factor into any of this anymore? Have we become that dependent on sound bites and empty rhetoric? I've read more articles on how the candidates are handling the press than I have on what the candidates actually intend to do.
I usually love the freedom to ignore the stupid "never talk politics or religion" rule during the campaign season. I enjoy little more than getting all fired up in a lively debate, but I'm getting nothing this year. No one seems interested in telling me why $700 billion to bail out spoiled bankers and insurers couldn't have been better spent on alternative fuel technology or why $2 billion a week in Iraq for the last five years couldn't have put electric or hydrogen cars on the road or at least bought a little health insurance for a few folks. Speaking of that, no one seems to want to apply the deregulation model (that did SO well with our mortgage institutions) to the insurance industry and predict when we'll have to bail them out as well once they finally price the rest of us out of their system and offer very little actual medical care in return.
I don't even bother explaining why I'll put up with some of Obama's bad ideas in exchange for a level-headed, intelligent, buck-stops-here type of leader with proven management ability anymore. It's so easy to support, it's not even fun. I mean, compare his opportunities and successes with the achievements W racked up before the White House... seriously. How does "failed baseball team" compare with "turned down top law firms after graduating at the top of my class at Harvard Law?" Or how about "failed Texas oil company bought out by the Saudis" against "successfully reclaimed dead neighborhoods" Or what about "awol from the Guard(and Vietnam) to pursue failed senate campaign" vs. "successful senate campaign" Or even "rehab, dui, sealed coke arrests" vs. "yeah, I smoked pot"
I know, I know, O's not running against W. How about the Repub convention rallying around their "service" signs one night, then picking on Obama's service to his community the next. (are slogans and chants really more important than actually doing something?) And if we must inject religion into the debate - though it should have even less relevance than the other non-issues I've mentioned, then O's definitely the man. We know what church he's attended consistently at least since his early Chicago days. We used his pastor against him! His opponent listed himself as one religion on his senate bio but didn't attend any church until he showed up at a "competing" venue one Sunday before the campaign began in earnest, but I guess his VP more than makes up for his lack of spiritual conviction.
And how about the family values as representatives of character and integrity? One guy's still married to his first wife. The other... well, I think it's all out of my system by now. I need to get to bed.
Thanks for listening.
Luth
Out
First, I must repeat it once again, I used to like this McCain guy. If he remains a senator I probably will again AFTER this election is over, but COME ON. How can anyone seriously be considering voting for this guy after the last seven years, the nasty campaign, the lessons learned over a similar 12-year experiment under Reagan and Bush 41 that resulted in a triple double (inflation, interest rates and unemployment) and the initial steps toward the deregulation that dumped today's economic crisis in our laps on top of everything else right now?
Does an attractive VP who says the right things on TV REALLY wash away her career that flies in the face of those TV promises? Wasn't her selection so blatant and obvious an attempt to inject gender and age (Hillary voters) to the ticket that even the most right-leaning Repub HAS to see through it? Even long-time Repubs are asking if there wasn't someone more qualified he could have picked... some congresswoman or governor. And how does family values now include pregnant, unwed teens? Isn't that what the family values folks always told us they'd do away with? Doesn't it strike anyone else as disingenuous at best that "at least she didn't abort" has become the standard to replace "just say no?!"
Are a few TV promises that are clearly contradictory to the pair's track record really all it takes to leave us in the complacency... now downward spiral where we don't even care about the issues as long as we get the party right? Are folks so bent on their party loyalty that the BS of the campaign is all it takes to make us forget our jobs, our homes, our health care, our children's futures, our common sense?
Look. If you don't like Obama or the Democratic Party that much, then vote for Ron Paul or Ralph Nader, or just don't even vote. I never thought I'd say that, but how can you seriously consider McCain-Palin? Sure they're NOT the SAME as W, but they HAVE based their campaign on supporting his two favorite issues: the economy and the war. On those issues, they may not be the same, but they're certainly in the same camp and where has it gotten us? After choosing the candidate with whom you'd rather have a beer, can't we agree that being just like us isn't the best reason to choose the guy in the top post? Hell, if that's your criteria, then I want to be your president. I'm fun to have a beer with!
Yes, this is a challenge for someone to convince me that McCain is still the guy I thought he was as a senator who got the job done. It's the second time I've issued this challenge. If you bother to read more than the one little detail you came here to either agree with or rail against, you'd know that I'll consider just about any argument. I'll defend my position, but I'll also listen intently to and seriously weigh those of others. I've listened throughout the campaigns believing, at least at the beginning, that it would be the first in my lifetime that actually offered us two good choices as opposed to the lesser of two evils. I no longer believe that and given the lunacy of the McCain campaign, I can't believe anyone is still falling for it to the point that it's even remotely close.
Look, I'm not a Democrat. I'm an independent with a little "i" because it's not a party. I vote for the best candidate regardless of party and I've voted for more Repubs in the last 10 years than I have Dems. I'm liberal in that I expect others to consider new ideas and to bear some responsibility for the welfare of others when they can. I'm conservative when it comes to personal responsibility, including that responsibility to occasionally be my brother's keeper when I have the means and he has the need. And I really think that my fellow voters have a responsibility to give me something better than the party line to explain why this guy is still a viable presidential candidate. I really tried to find it on my own and I'm simply stunned that it just doesn't seem to be there when you strip away the party trappings and yet, the polls have it as just a few point difference. Somebody explain that to me.
Does anyone out there honestly believe McCain is backing out of the debate in order to save our economy after he worked so hard to do away with the kinds of regulation we're now considering imposing? C'mon. He's got no chance to come out of that debate with anything but lost support and he knows it. Like Obama or not, he's going to clean up... or maybe not. Maybe the debate is what I need to change my mind, but without McCain involved, I won't get the chance, so somebody's got to help me see what half of our polled voters see in this ticket. Broaden my perspective before the debate... or before McCain ducks it.
W is talking legacy still and it's time we all consider what that might actually be... first and foremost there's the war. No matter how you feel about that, the legacy of how it was sold to us and how it's gone thus far is not going to be pretty. Then there's the nationalizing of the banking industry - the closest move toward socialism we've had since the Depression all while telling us out the other side of the face that nationalized health care is a bad idea and government should keep its hands off industry. Then there's the growing divide between the top 1% of wage earners and the bottom 99% which was supposed to materialize into/trickle down by creating all kinds of economic growth but instead resulted in all kinds of foreign ownership and record unemployment. And finally there's what all of this luxury will cost us: yep the national debt! Now that's a legacy our great grandchildren can share!
Thus far, McCain has promised to shore up that legacy by augmenting it. He wants the war to continue to be the biggest drain on our economy indefinitely with no objectives to signal its success or failure or completion. He'll make up for that, apparently, by admitting that his laissez-fair economic policy for the last 26 years was wrong then borrowing even more taxpayer money to bail out the campaign contributors who benefited most from those policies and whose golden parachutes are apparently not enough to sustain them while the rest of us fall farther and farther into the hole supporting them by running their plants and building their products for paychecks that buy less and less and benefits that are all but extinct.
Does anyone out there still think that someone's stance on gay marriage or abortion means more than a rat's ass compared to the issues the next president must solve? Are those two issues and gun laws REALLY what we're voting on this year? Does a label like conservative or liberal or Dem or Repub REALLY factor into any of this anymore? Have we become that dependent on sound bites and empty rhetoric? I've read more articles on how the candidates are handling the press than I have on what the candidates actually intend to do.
I usually love the freedom to ignore the stupid "never talk politics or religion" rule during the campaign season. I enjoy little more than getting all fired up in a lively debate, but I'm getting nothing this year. No one seems interested in telling me why $700 billion to bail out spoiled bankers and insurers couldn't have been better spent on alternative fuel technology or why $2 billion a week in Iraq for the last five years couldn't have put electric or hydrogen cars on the road or at least bought a little health insurance for a few folks. Speaking of that, no one seems to want to apply the deregulation model (that did SO well with our mortgage institutions) to the insurance industry and predict when we'll have to bail them out as well once they finally price the rest of us out of their system and offer very little actual medical care in return.
I don't even bother explaining why I'll put up with some of Obama's bad ideas in exchange for a level-headed, intelligent, buck-stops-here type of leader with proven management ability anymore. It's so easy to support, it's not even fun. I mean, compare his opportunities and successes with the achievements W racked up before the White House... seriously. How does "failed baseball team" compare with "turned down top law firms after graduating at the top of my class at Harvard Law?" Or how about "failed Texas oil company bought out by the Saudis" against "successfully reclaimed dead neighborhoods" Or what about "awol from the Guard(and Vietnam) to pursue failed senate campaign" vs. "successful senate campaign" Or even "rehab, dui, sealed coke arrests" vs. "yeah, I smoked pot"
I know, I know, O's not running against W. How about the Repub convention rallying around their "service" signs one night, then picking on Obama's service to his community the next. (are slogans and chants really more important than actually doing something?) And if we must inject religion into the debate - though it should have even less relevance than the other non-issues I've mentioned, then O's definitely the man. We know what church he's attended consistently at least since his early Chicago days. We used his pastor against him! His opponent listed himself as one religion on his senate bio but didn't attend any church until he showed up at a "competing" venue one Sunday before the campaign began in earnest, but I guess his VP more than makes up for his lack of spiritual conviction.
And how about the family values as representatives of character and integrity? One guy's still married to his first wife. The other... well, I think it's all out of my system by now. I need to get to bed.
Thanks for listening.
Luth
Out
Saturday, September 20, 2008
Two Thumbs Up for Obsession
The sweetie and I were discussing what kind of movie we might watch Friday night when I noticed that both she and my mom got copies of a movie in the mail. At first I thought it was just some chick flick trailer, but the closer I looked, the more I realized it said it was the whole movie inside the very professionally printed envelope so I suggested we check it out.
The movie was called Obsession: Radical Islam’s War Against the West. It didn’t sound like anything we’d normally pick from the list available on cable or the local movie rental, but we like to mix it up a little every now and then so we decided to give it a shot. While sweetie finished up some to-do list items I read some more of the info on this weird envelope. I learned that the movie inside would teach me about a very serious threat that few Americans take seriously enough. I learned that the movie was paid for by the Clarion Fund and that it wasn’t rated by the MPAA.
That wasn’t much to go on so I Googled “Clarion Fund” and visited their web page. Turns out they’re “a non-profit, non-partisan organization whose mission is to educate Americans about issues of national security.” Says they're a 501c3. Wikipedia told me a 501c3 is an organization most recognized as a religious non-profit, but that non-religious organizations can claim the status as well as long as they don’t “conduct political campaign activities to influence elections to public office.” This still didn’t tell me anything about the movie, so I clicked a link on the home page that took me to RadicalIslam.org. The logo of their header uses the twin towers as the “l” at the end of “radical” and the “I” at the beginning of “Islam.” The page is copyrighted by The Clarion Fund. Buttons on this page led to “Shari a Law, Radical Islam Overview, Fueling Terror, and Vote 2008.” I clicked on the "Vote 2008" button, not 'cuz I thought it would tell me about the movie, but because I'm kind of a political junkie. (perhaps you've noticed)
Links there took me to either McCain’s pages of anti-terror policy or to Obama’s or I could watch a short video called “The Stakes” which just showed a bunch of pictures of Muslims in traditional garb with angry expressions and ended with a picture of McCain and lots of text floating in and out bearing ominous warnings. I clicked a few more links from the Google search results and learned that this movie we were going to watch had been included as “paid advertising” in newpapers delivered to 28 million U.S. homes this week, but only homes in swing states. The “advertising” was paid for by the Clarion Fund. Strangely, I couldn't find out much more about The Clarion Fund or about the movie.
I gave up on learning any more about the movie and sweetie had finally made it to the couch so we fired up the DVD. Two disclaimers came first. One warned of the graphic nature of the movie. The other noted that the majority of Muslims are peace-loving people and that this movie was not about them. The movie then opened with video of the second plane hitting the twin towers followed by a series of other terrorist incidents and interviews with journalists, think-tank researchers, former terrorists and a few others interspersed with footage, often poorly shot, of radical Islamic fellows yelling hateful things (subtitled in English) to variously sized crowds, and scenes from terrorist strikes throughout the world.
15 minutes was about all we could stand, but we did skip to the beginning of each of the remaining chapters, sampling them to see if this pattern would change. We'd stop and read the chapter titles like "understanding the jihad culture" then watch for a while hoping we'd actually see some Arab culture, but instead it was just more video of some radical televangelist performing for a crowd of loyal followers.
Five minutes is all it took to convince us that instead of a free razor, pack of laundry detergent, or the other advertising items that often come in unsolicited mail or along with the Sunday paper, this particular delivery was pure propaganda. Then it occurred to me that it was clearly the propaganda out of the Carl Rove fear tactics playbook. That's when I went back and read the 501c3 restriction again about not campaigning for an elected official. Hmmm. Sounds like the IRS will be after someone soon!
As you might suspect, I couldn't wait to sign on to Poup where I would quickly tear Obsession a new one. I was going to talk about how un-subtle this endorsement of McCain really was... about how all this fear crap was clearly designed to retro-fit a legitimate reason for the invasion of Iraq... about how the comparisons of unnamed terrorist groups to Hitler's Reich were cheap, emotional appeals, but then I thought, "That's awfully narrow-minded of me. I must step back for a moment and see the bigger picture. Perhaps I've missed some detail that would make this film actually live up to the non-partisan claim of its sponsor." After all, my writing has been good therapy and has really helped me deal with those previous episodes of reactionary off the handle flying I used to do so frequently. It's time to grow up.
I was shocked at the results of this stunning display of maturity. Suddenly the scenes of the movie began to gel into one of the most powerful, non-partisan, rational statements I've ever seen in a free mailing arriving unsolicited to my mom and my wife. (I wonder why I didn't get my own copy?)
I was so ready to believe this secretly funded, produced, and covertly delivered piece of propaganda was the work of the Red Right Radicals that I almost missed the true, totally obvious message of the film. You'd think I'd learned not to do that anymore.
So yeah, there I was replaying the Hitler scenes in my mind when I also thought, don't trust your mind... you know where that's gotten you before, watch the damned movie again. So I replayed the scenes where Neville Chamberlain returns triumphantly with the accord Hitler signed bringing peace to Europe. And the scenes where Hitler's followers in Africa and Palestine met with him and promised to deliver nations of people ready to help him exterminate the Jews. Hitler was a big fan of the Muslims I guess. And, you have to admit, it would be an easy mistake to simply associate all things Muslim with all things Nazi at that point.
Somewhere in the middle of these scenes, former PLO terrorist Walid Shoebat, who makes quite a few contributions to the movie, notes that it takes more than just desperation and brainwashing to get people to act like this. Hitler may have been charismatic, but that alone doesn't move people to genocide. Shoebat says, "the secular fascism of the Nazis was far less dangerous than the Islamofascists of today because Islamofascism has a religious twist to it. It says God, the almighty ordered you to do this, not just the fuehrer."
And therein lies the real message of the film. I'm afraid; however, that it will be misinterpreted, so now I'll give a chapter by chapter translation of the film's main points:
Chapter 1: The Culture of Terror
Nonie Darwish, daughter of Palestinian suicide "martyr" explains that hers was a childhood of terrorism.
Translation: My father gave his life while taking the lives of others for his God. That was our (religious) culture.
Ch. 2: The Culture of Jihad
Several experts explain that the most accurate translation of Jihad is "struggle" or "personal struggle" or "inner struggle" proving that Muslims are not to be feared... followed by footage of radical Muslims doing frightening things.
Translation: Religion allows many irrational interpretations of its word leading to many frightening things.
Ch 3: The Culture of Hatred
A series of radical clerics tell stories on TV mostly based in one way or another on the blood libel that Jews (or any Westerners) use the blood of children or the elderly in various recipes. OR motivational films depicting all Western symbols as Demonic or Satanic.
Translation: Religious leaders use deceit to build and then manipulate their congregations. They create enemies with lies and proclaimed partnerships with the Devil. (your flock will only fight if they believe there is a threat)
Ch 4: The Media of Terrorism
This one's pretty funny actually. It starts with two kaftan-wearing folks in the Sunday political talk show format discussing the idea that Arab media pushes kids to terrorism, or at least violent fanaticism. They're subtitled in English. It sure looks like the interviewee is actually complaining, NOT bragging about this, especially when he goes on to say that starting suicide bomber training so young robs the youth of their childhood... that we "teach them how to die for Allah, but we don't teach them how to live for Allah." I'm not sure why this "evidence" that they are evil was included, but I'll still attempt a translation. (anyway, then the movie jumps to a series of bad MTV-like videos both humorous and frightening made my radical groups)
Translation: Any argument that stems from religion is, by definition, irrational. This particular argument is SO irrational that it fails to separate out that which does not make its case, but rather, seems to prove otherwise. By the way, it struck me as funny whenever the movie broke to its interviewees who then decried the Arabic media for doing exactly what they were doing. Let's face it, if I flipped the channels through the televangelist series, I could pick out some equally radical sounding footage of Christian "clerics" doing the same thing this chapter accuses ALL Muslim clerics of doing. Americans have heard a good 3 minutes of one Rev. Jeremiah Wright sermon and we've made up our minds about his 40 years as a preacher, right?
Ch 5: Jihad in the West
The "infiltration" of radical Islam in the West is described as the spreading of seeds. Hints of denial are included as foreshadowing for the next chapter, but the best scene is an interview wherein Dr. Ahmad Dwidar, Islamic Cleric (according to the footage) says he once heard a sermon that predicted that Muslims would march on the White House. When the interviewer asks what this means, Dr. Dwidar says, "through the domination and distribution of Islam, the White House will be changed. It will become a Muslim House." It's one of the most quiet, rational sounding pieces of footage featuring a "cleric" in the whole movie. It's such an obvious nod to the fact that Obama's middle name is Hussein that I almost laughed out loud.
Translation: The religious right in this country will stop at nothing to get their boy into the big house... including subtly hinting that his opponent is a seed being spread by radical Islamists - a thought they KNOW the ignorant among us already believe in spite of all evidence to the contrary. In other words, folks who claim to know more about what's right, largely due to some religious claim of a direct connection with God, as opposed to observing anything like evidence, are the same all over. They'll lie, they'll cheat, they'll steal in their own form of Jihad if that's what it takes to put their chosen people in power.
Ch 6: The Culture of Denial
Basically, the world is being taken over by radical Muslims and we're denying it.
Translation: The world is being taken over by religious fanatics of all types and we're denying it. The longer we hide behind "religious tolerance," denying the irrationality of religion and perpetuating the one remaining mythical god we've chosen to keep while recognizing all the others for the myths they are, the longer we subject ourselves to the violent actions of irrational people who believe they're doing the work of this god and will thus stop at nothing until all of that work is done.
Ch 7: The Common Denominators
The movie draws many comparisons among the Nazis and today's Radical Muslims (as though that were a fixed, definite group like the Nazis.
Translation: Dictators, especially those bent on destroying all those they don't like, are always justified by some higher power. (Just as Mien Kampf is similar in meaning to Jihad, so were the religious justifications of the Nazis to today's religious radicals) Christians destroying pagans in Rome, Muslims in Spain...
Ch 8: Hitler & the Mufti
Hitler quickly befriended radical Muslim leaders because they shared the goal of getting rid of the Jews.
Translation: Hitler quickly befriended radical religious leaders because he knew no reasonable people would buy his irrational bullshit.
Ch 9: What do Radical Muslims Want?
The same as Hitler wanted: to destroy the Jews, bring down the West.
Translation: What do all religious groups want: world domination... their brand of irrationality to be the entire world's brand of irrationality. Granted, some are happy to try to accomplish this by more peaceful means, but you can't deny that's what they want. Except maybe, for the Masons... cuz they don't come after you. (2B1Ask1) Though I've been subject to some coercion to "ask1" before just like all the others!
Ch 10: We've Been Here Before
History repeats itself.
Translation: No shit! (Ancient Rome, Christopher Columbus, The Crusades, St. Patrick, Salem Witch Trials, the Red Scare, Church of England, Branch Davidians, Jim Jones, pretty much every major war ever fought, you name it, we've seen it all before and yet, here we are again, tolerating the same irrationality in spite of the growing body of evidence against it.)
By the way again, the movie lists 13 chapters, but I didn't figure I needed to translate the intro credits, title scene, and I've already mentioned the disclaimer.
One more thing worthy of note: the movie begins and ends with the Edmund Burke quote:
"All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing."
Isn't it strange that they should quote a guy from a land where Christians ran off, converted, or killed all the pagans several hundred years ago and yet the land is still racked by the memories and lingering violence and hatred resulting from that invasion. It reminds one of a time when Christians played the role of today's radical Muslims. Hmmm, I guess history really does repeat itself... only the names change. You'd think that by now, the good men would have had their fill of this so-called source of all life, knowledge and morality they refer to as religion. You'd think by now we'd stop doing nothing and start calling for people to put aside their irrational beliefs and step into this modern world where physics, chemistry and biology really can shed light on most of the important questions.
So the movie turned out to be a pleasant surprise, but what's most surprising is that a work of the Right (and let's not pretend that it is otherwise) does such a great job of calling for the end of faith.
Bravo. Perhaps my loyalty really has been misplaced.
Luth,
Out.
The movie was called Obsession: Radical Islam’s War Against the West. It didn’t sound like anything we’d normally pick from the list available on cable or the local movie rental, but we like to mix it up a little every now and then so we decided to give it a shot. While sweetie finished up some to-do list items I read some more of the info on this weird envelope. I learned that the movie inside would teach me about a very serious threat that few Americans take seriously enough. I learned that the movie was paid for by the Clarion Fund and that it wasn’t rated by the MPAA.
That wasn’t much to go on so I Googled “Clarion Fund” and visited their web page. Turns out they’re “a non-profit, non-partisan organization whose mission is to educate Americans about issues of national security.” Says they're a 501c3. Wikipedia told me a 501c3 is an organization most recognized as a religious non-profit, but that non-religious organizations can claim the status as well as long as they don’t “conduct political campaign activities to influence elections to public office.” This still didn’t tell me anything about the movie, so I clicked a link on the home page that took me to RadicalIslam.org. The logo of their header uses the twin towers as the “l” at the end of “radical” and the “I” at the beginning of “Islam.” The page is copyrighted by The Clarion Fund. Buttons on this page led to “Shari a Law, Radical Islam Overview, Fueling Terror, and Vote 2008.” I clicked on the "Vote 2008" button, not 'cuz I thought it would tell me about the movie, but because I'm kind of a political junkie. (perhaps you've noticed)
Links there took me to either McCain’s pages of anti-terror policy or to Obama’s or I could watch a short video called “The Stakes” which just showed a bunch of pictures of Muslims in traditional garb with angry expressions and ended with a picture of McCain and lots of text floating in and out bearing ominous warnings. I clicked a few more links from the Google search results and learned that this movie we were going to watch had been included as “paid advertising” in newpapers delivered to 28 million U.S. homes this week, but only homes in swing states. The “advertising” was paid for by the Clarion Fund. Strangely, I couldn't find out much more about The Clarion Fund or about the movie.
I gave up on learning any more about the movie and sweetie had finally made it to the couch so we fired up the DVD. Two disclaimers came first. One warned of the graphic nature of the movie. The other noted that the majority of Muslims are peace-loving people and that this movie was not about them. The movie then opened with video of the second plane hitting the twin towers followed by a series of other terrorist incidents and interviews with journalists, think-tank researchers, former terrorists and a few others interspersed with footage, often poorly shot, of radical Islamic fellows yelling hateful things (subtitled in English) to variously sized crowds, and scenes from terrorist strikes throughout the world.
15 minutes was about all we could stand, but we did skip to the beginning of each of the remaining chapters, sampling them to see if this pattern would change. We'd stop and read the chapter titles like "understanding the jihad culture" then watch for a while hoping we'd actually see some Arab culture, but instead it was just more video of some radical televangelist performing for a crowd of loyal followers.
Five minutes is all it took to convince us that instead of a free razor, pack of laundry detergent, or the other advertising items that often come in unsolicited mail or along with the Sunday paper, this particular delivery was pure propaganda. Then it occurred to me that it was clearly the propaganda out of the Carl Rove fear tactics playbook. That's when I went back and read the 501c3 restriction again about not campaigning for an elected official. Hmmm. Sounds like the IRS will be after someone soon!
As you might suspect, I couldn't wait to sign on to Poup where I would quickly tear Obsession a new one. I was going to talk about how un-subtle this endorsement of McCain really was... about how all this fear crap was clearly designed to retro-fit a legitimate reason for the invasion of Iraq... about how the comparisons of unnamed terrorist groups to Hitler's Reich were cheap, emotional appeals, but then I thought, "That's awfully narrow-minded of me. I must step back for a moment and see the bigger picture. Perhaps I've missed some detail that would make this film actually live up to the non-partisan claim of its sponsor." After all, my writing has been good therapy and has really helped me deal with those previous episodes of reactionary off the handle flying I used to do so frequently. It's time to grow up.
I was shocked at the results of this stunning display of maturity. Suddenly the scenes of the movie began to gel into one of the most powerful, non-partisan, rational statements I've ever seen in a free mailing arriving unsolicited to my mom and my wife. (I wonder why I didn't get my own copy?)
I was so ready to believe this secretly funded, produced, and covertly delivered piece of propaganda was the work of the Red Right Radicals that I almost missed the true, totally obvious message of the film. You'd think I'd learned not to do that anymore.
So yeah, there I was replaying the Hitler scenes in my mind when I also thought, don't trust your mind... you know where that's gotten you before, watch the damned movie again. So I replayed the scenes where Neville Chamberlain returns triumphantly with the accord Hitler signed bringing peace to Europe. And the scenes where Hitler's followers in Africa and Palestine met with him and promised to deliver nations of people ready to help him exterminate the Jews. Hitler was a big fan of the Muslims I guess. And, you have to admit, it would be an easy mistake to simply associate all things Muslim with all things Nazi at that point.
Somewhere in the middle of these scenes, former PLO terrorist Walid Shoebat, who makes quite a few contributions to the movie, notes that it takes more than just desperation and brainwashing to get people to act like this. Hitler may have been charismatic, but that alone doesn't move people to genocide. Shoebat says, "the secular fascism of the Nazis was far less dangerous than the Islamofascists of today because Islamofascism has a religious twist to it. It says God, the almighty ordered you to do this, not just the fuehrer."
And therein lies the real message of the film. I'm afraid; however, that it will be misinterpreted, so now I'll give a chapter by chapter translation of the film's main points:
Chapter 1: The Culture of Terror
Nonie Darwish, daughter of Palestinian suicide "martyr" explains that hers was a childhood of terrorism.
Translation: My father gave his life while taking the lives of others for his God. That was our (religious) culture.
Ch. 2: The Culture of Jihad
Several experts explain that the most accurate translation of Jihad is "struggle" or "personal struggle" or "inner struggle" proving that Muslims are not to be feared... followed by footage of radical Muslims doing frightening things.
Translation: Religion allows many irrational interpretations of its word leading to many frightening things.
Ch 3: The Culture of Hatred
A series of radical clerics tell stories on TV mostly based in one way or another on the blood libel that Jews (or any Westerners) use the blood of children or the elderly in various recipes. OR motivational films depicting all Western symbols as Demonic or Satanic.
Translation: Religious leaders use deceit to build and then manipulate their congregations. They create enemies with lies and proclaimed partnerships with the Devil. (your flock will only fight if they believe there is a threat)
Ch 4: The Media of Terrorism
This one's pretty funny actually. It starts with two kaftan-wearing folks in the Sunday political talk show format discussing the idea that Arab media pushes kids to terrorism, or at least violent fanaticism. They're subtitled in English. It sure looks like the interviewee is actually complaining, NOT bragging about this, especially when he goes on to say that starting suicide bomber training so young robs the youth of their childhood... that we "teach them how to die for Allah, but we don't teach them how to live for Allah." I'm not sure why this "evidence" that they are evil was included, but I'll still attempt a translation. (anyway, then the movie jumps to a series of bad MTV-like videos both humorous and frightening made my radical groups)
Translation: Any argument that stems from religion is, by definition, irrational. This particular argument is SO irrational that it fails to separate out that which does not make its case, but rather, seems to prove otherwise. By the way, it struck me as funny whenever the movie broke to its interviewees who then decried the Arabic media for doing exactly what they were doing. Let's face it, if I flipped the channels through the televangelist series, I could pick out some equally radical sounding footage of Christian "clerics" doing the same thing this chapter accuses ALL Muslim clerics of doing. Americans have heard a good 3 minutes of one Rev. Jeremiah Wright sermon and we've made up our minds about his 40 years as a preacher, right?
Ch 5: Jihad in the West
The "infiltration" of radical Islam in the West is described as the spreading of seeds. Hints of denial are included as foreshadowing for the next chapter, but the best scene is an interview wherein Dr. Ahmad Dwidar, Islamic Cleric (according to the footage) says he once heard a sermon that predicted that Muslims would march on the White House. When the interviewer asks what this means, Dr. Dwidar says, "through the domination and distribution of Islam, the White House will be changed. It will become a Muslim House." It's one of the most quiet, rational sounding pieces of footage featuring a "cleric" in the whole movie. It's such an obvious nod to the fact that Obama's middle name is Hussein that I almost laughed out loud.
Translation: The religious right in this country will stop at nothing to get their boy into the big house... including subtly hinting that his opponent is a seed being spread by radical Islamists - a thought they KNOW the ignorant among us already believe in spite of all evidence to the contrary. In other words, folks who claim to know more about what's right, largely due to some religious claim of a direct connection with God, as opposed to observing anything like evidence, are the same all over. They'll lie, they'll cheat, they'll steal in their own form of Jihad if that's what it takes to put their chosen people in power.
Ch 6: The Culture of Denial
Basically, the world is being taken over by radical Muslims and we're denying it.
Translation: The world is being taken over by religious fanatics of all types and we're denying it. The longer we hide behind "religious tolerance," denying the irrationality of religion and perpetuating the one remaining mythical god we've chosen to keep while recognizing all the others for the myths they are, the longer we subject ourselves to the violent actions of irrational people who believe they're doing the work of this god and will thus stop at nothing until all of that work is done.
Ch 7: The Common Denominators
The movie draws many comparisons among the Nazis and today's Radical Muslims (as though that were a fixed, definite group like the Nazis.
Translation: Dictators, especially those bent on destroying all those they don't like, are always justified by some higher power. (Just as Mien Kampf is similar in meaning to Jihad, so were the religious justifications of the Nazis to today's religious radicals) Christians destroying pagans in Rome, Muslims in Spain...
Ch 8: Hitler & the Mufti
Hitler quickly befriended radical Muslim leaders because they shared the goal of getting rid of the Jews.
Translation: Hitler quickly befriended radical religious leaders because he knew no reasonable people would buy his irrational bullshit.
Ch 9: What do Radical Muslims Want?
The same as Hitler wanted: to destroy the Jews, bring down the West.
Translation: What do all religious groups want: world domination... their brand of irrationality to be the entire world's brand of irrationality. Granted, some are happy to try to accomplish this by more peaceful means, but you can't deny that's what they want. Except maybe, for the Masons... cuz they don't come after you. (2B1Ask1) Though I've been subject to some coercion to "ask1" before just like all the others!
Ch 10: We've Been Here Before
History repeats itself.
Translation: No shit! (Ancient Rome, Christopher Columbus, The Crusades, St. Patrick, Salem Witch Trials, the Red Scare, Church of England, Branch Davidians, Jim Jones, pretty much every major war ever fought, you name it, we've seen it all before and yet, here we are again, tolerating the same irrationality in spite of the growing body of evidence against it.)
By the way again, the movie lists 13 chapters, but I didn't figure I needed to translate the intro credits, title scene, and I've already mentioned the disclaimer.
One more thing worthy of note: the movie begins and ends with the Edmund Burke quote:
"All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing."
Isn't it strange that they should quote a guy from a land where Christians ran off, converted, or killed all the pagans several hundred years ago and yet the land is still racked by the memories and lingering violence and hatred resulting from that invasion. It reminds one of a time when Christians played the role of today's radical Muslims. Hmmm, I guess history really does repeat itself... only the names change. You'd think that by now, the good men would have had their fill of this so-called source of all life, knowledge and morality they refer to as religion. You'd think by now we'd stop doing nothing and start calling for people to put aside their irrational beliefs and step into this modern world where physics, chemistry and biology really can shed light on most of the important questions.
So the movie turned out to be a pleasant surprise, but what's most surprising is that a work of the Right (and let's not pretend that it is otherwise) does such a great job of calling for the end of faith.
Bravo. Perhaps my loyalty really has been misplaced.
Luth,
Out.
Thursday, August 21, 2008
It's been a while
What's up kids? Miss me? Yeah, me neither. I just got back from a whirlwind tour: a week in DC, a weekend camping at Camp Perry Air National Guard Station, and a week in Memphis. I enjoyed all of it, but this has been my first week back, it's already Thursday, and it feels like three weeks of my life disappeared in a blink. At this time next spring, not having that Guard weekend in the middle of it will make all the difference!
I took the fam to DC with me - their first time there - and that was nice, although sharing a hotel room that is usually silent after 7 pm with 4 women (my niece joined us) presented a level of noise until all hours for which I wasn't completely prepared. (I was the only one who had to be to work by 7:30). It was an entirely enjoyable trip though.
We began our visit the Monday before my work started so we did the monuments/National Mall walking tour that day. We were lucky that the forecasted 95 degrees never materialized. It never topped 90 so it wasn't too bad, but we walked our butts off starting at the Smithsonian Metro stop, north to the Mall, then west down the Mall to the Washington Monument, north around the White House, only stopping for a brief break in the White House visitor center air conditioning, west again to the Vietnam and Declaration Signers memorials, the Lincoln Memorial, back east along the south war memorials (Korea, DC War, and JP Jones) and then we finished up that evening at the WWII Memorial before eating dinner back near the hotel in Alexandria.
We did another night at Arlington Cemetery watching two guard changes, a night walking up and down King St. in Old Town, and the ladies spent their days in the hotel pool, the Pentagon City Mall, and the Hirshorn Museum. Then we headed back home after I finished up my program on Friday. I headed off to Guard Saturday and Sunday, then caught a plane to Memphis Monday morning. I didn't make it to Graceland, but I ate a lot of barbecue, and spent my Thursday afternoon (after finishing up work) in the Civil Rights Museum at the Lorraine Motel.
I was there by about 1:00 and figured I'd breeze through and maybe even get to Graceland before I had to be at the airport by 6. Though I'd seen most of the video footage on display, the level of depth of the other displays was completely engrossing, and for a white guy who is rather fond of his homeland, more than a little embarrassing. One video I hadn't seen was of the treatment of black diners protesting by sitting in a whites only diner. How those folks remained as passive as they did amazes me. That's strength, courage, and a payment made that most of us never even think to repay. The big names have been immortalized, as they should, but the names of a lot of other courageous folks are long forgotten.
Another exhibit that caught my attention was a recording of the phone call between President Kennedy and Mississippi Governor Ross Barnett after Ole Miss refused to admit James Meredith. Not only did Barnett flat out lie to the President, he sounded like some spoiled teenager speaking disrespectfully to a parent.
I'll admit to all the Bush bashing I've done on this stupid old 'blog, but if he were to call my office on the phone, you bet your ass I'd be calling him "sir" and trying to find a way to do whatever he asked. Barnett didn't seem to grasp who he was talking to or what he was arguing about. I was in the main building for almost 3hours. Standing between the rooms MLK Jr. occupied that day was more than a little creepy, but nowhere near as creepy as what came next.
The self guided tour ends after you go across the street to the boarding house where James Earl Ray rented a room. The display there turns all CSI on you, which helps wash some of the embarrassment from your brain after being reminded of just how stupid we can be as a group. I'm not much of a conspiracy theory guy, but the collection of details, evidence, and information on display there aroused more than a little doubt about the idea of Ray as a deranged loner acting completely on his own.
If you claim to love this country, you have to spend some time there. Beale Street takes some of the sting off of wondering which side of the civil rights movement you'd have been caught up in if you had been alive back then. It's easy to see how stupid people were back then, but times have changed significantly and I'm afraid I'm not so sure how I would have acted without 40 years of hindsight between me/now and society back then. I'd like to think my sense of fairness and justice is inherent and would have prevailed had I been born a generation earlier, but I just don't know. It was a great lesson in the importance of history lest we repeat the same mistakes.
Anyhoo, it's past my bedtime. Type at ya later.
Luth
I took the fam to DC with me - their first time there - and that was nice, although sharing a hotel room that is usually silent after 7 pm with 4 women (my niece joined us) presented a level of noise until all hours for which I wasn't completely prepared. (I was the only one who had to be to work by 7:30). It was an entirely enjoyable trip though.
We began our visit the Monday before my work started so we did the monuments/National Mall walking tour that day. We were lucky that the forecasted 95 degrees never materialized. It never topped 90 so it wasn't too bad, but we walked our butts off starting at the Smithsonian Metro stop, north to the Mall, then west down the Mall to the Washington Monument, north around the White House, only stopping for a brief break in the White House visitor center air conditioning, west again to the Vietnam and Declaration Signers memorials, the Lincoln Memorial, back east along the south war memorials (Korea, DC War, and JP Jones) and then we finished up that evening at the WWII Memorial before eating dinner back near the hotel in Alexandria.
We did another night at Arlington Cemetery watching two guard changes, a night walking up and down King St. in Old Town, and the ladies spent their days in the hotel pool, the Pentagon City Mall, and the Hirshorn Museum. Then we headed back home after I finished up my program on Friday. I headed off to Guard Saturday and Sunday, then caught a plane to Memphis Monday morning. I didn't make it to Graceland, but I ate a lot of barbecue, and spent my Thursday afternoon (after finishing up work) in the Civil Rights Museum at the Lorraine Motel.
I was there by about 1:00 and figured I'd breeze through and maybe even get to Graceland before I had to be at the airport by 6. Though I'd seen most of the video footage on display, the level of depth of the other displays was completely engrossing, and for a white guy who is rather fond of his homeland, more than a little embarrassing. One video I hadn't seen was of the treatment of black diners protesting by sitting in a whites only diner. How those folks remained as passive as they did amazes me. That's strength, courage, and a payment made that most of us never even think to repay. The big names have been immortalized, as they should, but the names of a lot of other courageous folks are long forgotten.
Another exhibit that caught my attention was a recording of the phone call between President Kennedy and Mississippi Governor Ross Barnett after Ole Miss refused to admit James Meredith. Not only did Barnett flat out lie to the President, he sounded like some spoiled teenager speaking disrespectfully to a parent.
I'll admit to all the Bush bashing I've done on this stupid old 'blog, but if he were to call my office on the phone, you bet your ass I'd be calling him "sir" and trying to find a way to do whatever he asked. Barnett didn't seem to grasp who he was talking to or what he was arguing about. I was in the main building for almost 3hours. Standing between the rooms MLK Jr. occupied that day was more than a little creepy, but nowhere near as creepy as what came next.
The self guided tour ends after you go across the street to the boarding house where James Earl Ray rented a room. The display there turns all CSI on you, which helps wash some of the embarrassment from your brain after being reminded of just how stupid we can be as a group. I'm not much of a conspiracy theory guy, but the collection of details, evidence, and information on display there aroused more than a little doubt about the idea of Ray as a deranged loner acting completely on his own.
If you claim to love this country, you have to spend some time there. Beale Street takes some of the sting off of wondering which side of the civil rights movement you'd have been caught up in if you had been alive back then. It's easy to see how stupid people were back then, but times have changed significantly and I'm afraid I'm not so sure how I would have acted without 40 years of hindsight between me/now and society back then. I'd like to think my sense of fairness and justice is inherent and would have prevailed had I been born a generation earlier, but I just don't know. It was a great lesson in the importance of history lest we repeat the same mistakes.
Anyhoo, it's past my bedtime. Type at ya later.
Luth
Monday, July 28, 2008
Toeing the Party Line*
I'm truly curious about some of the new ideas John McCain has embraced now that he's the national party's presumptive nominee for president. I say "truly" because I really want to know how these changes came about. What new information has he become privy to that changed his mind. Perhaps mine will be changed too. It's happened. I've always argued that there's an important distinction between "flip-floppery" and growth. (an argument I often lost when using John Kerry as the example)
I also fully understand that when a politician makes his way from independent local maverick to national party nominee, he's got to take on some of the party's planks even if they conflict with his (or her) long-held or at least -espoused beliefs. So I'm really not being facetious here, but rather, seeking to understand better how someone like Senator McCain, for whom I've professed my love as an independent, non-partisan, roll up the sleeves and get to work, servant of the American public many times before, can do 180s on some issues I would have thought he'd hold onto regardless of party pressures.
Let's start with abortion. McCain's shifted position on this issue is dear to my heart precisely because it's the last thing that should ever come up in a presidential campaign featuring two male candidates. Yep, you've heard me say it before and I'll say it again, abortion is the last issue I'd ever ask about when vetting a presidential candidate. When I run for president, I'll refuse to comment on it. The immediate issues facing the world's most powerful leader render the abortion debate senseless, moot, irrelevant. Stupid to even bring it up. And since it's a non issue, I'd think McCain would just keep to himself about it. Or at least keep to what he used to say he believed about it. After all, these are usually very personal, private, deeply held beliefs, not something subject to change based solely on elect-ablility. So I'm curious as to what the National Republican Party placed before him to change his mind. Perhaps, contrary to what President Bush says about diplomacy, there's an argument I haven't heard. I'm nothing if not curious.
Likewise, his stance on gay marriage seems to be evolving. He voted against a constitutional ban on gay marriage and he supported California's Prop 8 to allow gay marriage in that state, yet he's sounding more and more like the party line against it these days adding "I believe marriage is between a man and a woman" whenever he talks about it and arguing in favor of the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy in spite of recognizing the need for more troops as well as being extremely proud, in his own words, of ALL of our troops. I'll buy his "it's an issue best left to the states" argument on the marriage part, but when it comes to everything concerning the rights of gay people, I not only need to know what changed McCain's mind, but where his mind might eventually settle. We'll leave that one out for now.
The last and most important issue now, but one that will be completely irrelevant in just a few more months, was McCain's position on running a positive, clean campaign. Let's argue our own merits and platforms and leave the other guy to argue for his own is what he used to profess and yet, the last two commercials McCain's campaign has aired, at least in my part of the country spend 25 of their 30 seconds talking about Obama. McCain has criticized something Obama has done on the campaign trail in every speech I've seen aired for the last two weeks. In fact, after concluding his own Middle Eastern and European tour, McCain now criticizes Obama for doing the same thing, making many of the same stops. Not only has he changed his mind about running a positive campaign, he seems to have changed his mind about where a candidate is allowed to visit as well. I expect such hypocrisy from the Party in general, but not from the maverick from Arizona! This guy didn't cave after 5 years of torture and enslavement, but he folds to his sometimes party like a well worn laundry?!
I'm suddenly changing my mind about this election being the first in my lifetime that offers something better than just the lesser of two evils. McCain's lack of focus, infamous temper, and sudden willingness to conform to his party's every whim in spite of his successful career based on just the opposite have all but convinced me the man is not fit for the White House. I can't tell you how disappointed I am to actually begin considering this after the hope with which I began watching this race unfold.
What kills me now is, how is McCain even remaining as close to Obama as he is? The conservatives don't like him. No one seems to like the Republican Party anymore. His campaign has suffered key personnel losses and a seeming lack of focus and yet he's trailing Mr. Charisma and the finest tuned campaign since Reagan's by only a few points. Do people still believe Obama's a Muslim contracted to infiltrate us? Or are we really that racist yet? Do folks not understand that he trailed Hillary's political experience by only one year? Does the fact that the most sought after Harvard Law graduate gave up offers from prestigious firms to go back and work to reclaim the neighborhoods where he grew up in Chicago not counter the specious cries of "elitist?" And even if it doesn't, haven't we learned that an elite president might just be a little more effective than "the one you'd rather have a beer with?"
Go Tribe!
(yeah, I've seen their record... this will very shortly be replaced with Go Browns!)
Luth,
Out
*look it up... although this is the original figure of speech, what McCain is doing these days is more closely described by the mistaken "towing the line." Ha, that's pretty funny!
I also fully understand that when a politician makes his way from independent local maverick to national party nominee, he's got to take on some of the party's planks even if they conflict with his (or her) long-held or at least -espoused beliefs. So I'm really not being facetious here, but rather, seeking to understand better how someone like Senator McCain, for whom I've professed my love as an independent, non-partisan, roll up the sleeves and get to work, servant of the American public many times before, can do 180s on some issues I would have thought he'd hold onto regardless of party pressures.
Let's start with abortion. McCain's shifted position on this issue is dear to my heart precisely because it's the last thing that should ever come up in a presidential campaign featuring two male candidates. Yep, you've heard me say it before and I'll say it again, abortion is the last issue I'd ever ask about when vetting a presidential candidate. When I run for president, I'll refuse to comment on it. The immediate issues facing the world's most powerful leader render the abortion debate senseless, moot, irrelevant. Stupid to even bring it up. And since it's a non issue, I'd think McCain would just keep to himself about it. Or at least keep to what he used to say he believed about it. After all, these are usually very personal, private, deeply held beliefs, not something subject to change based solely on elect-ablility. So I'm curious as to what the National Republican Party placed before him to change his mind. Perhaps, contrary to what President Bush says about diplomacy, there's an argument I haven't heard. I'm nothing if not curious.
Likewise, his stance on gay marriage seems to be evolving. He voted against a constitutional ban on gay marriage and he supported California's Prop 8 to allow gay marriage in that state, yet he's sounding more and more like the party line against it these days adding "I believe marriage is between a man and a woman" whenever he talks about it and arguing in favor of the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy in spite of recognizing the need for more troops as well as being extremely proud, in his own words, of ALL of our troops. I'll buy his "it's an issue best left to the states" argument on the marriage part, but when it comes to everything concerning the rights of gay people, I not only need to know what changed McCain's mind, but where his mind might eventually settle. We'll leave that one out for now.
The last and most important issue now, but one that will be completely irrelevant in just a few more months, was McCain's position on running a positive, clean campaign. Let's argue our own merits and platforms and leave the other guy to argue for his own is what he used to profess and yet, the last two commercials McCain's campaign has aired, at least in my part of the country spend 25 of their 30 seconds talking about Obama. McCain has criticized something Obama has done on the campaign trail in every speech I've seen aired for the last two weeks. In fact, after concluding his own Middle Eastern and European tour, McCain now criticizes Obama for doing the same thing, making many of the same stops. Not only has he changed his mind about running a positive campaign, he seems to have changed his mind about where a candidate is allowed to visit as well. I expect such hypocrisy from the Party in general, but not from the maverick from Arizona! This guy didn't cave after 5 years of torture and enslavement, but he folds to his sometimes party like a well worn laundry?!
I'm suddenly changing my mind about this election being the first in my lifetime that offers something better than just the lesser of two evils. McCain's lack of focus, infamous temper, and sudden willingness to conform to his party's every whim in spite of his successful career based on just the opposite have all but convinced me the man is not fit for the White House. I can't tell you how disappointed I am to actually begin considering this after the hope with which I began watching this race unfold.
What kills me now is, how is McCain even remaining as close to Obama as he is? The conservatives don't like him. No one seems to like the Republican Party anymore. His campaign has suffered key personnel losses and a seeming lack of focus and yet he's trailing Mr. Charisma and the finest tuned campaign since Reagan's by only a few points. Do people still believe Obama's a Muslim contracted to infiltrate us? Or are we really that racist yet? Do folks not understand that he trailed Hillary's political experience by only one year? Does the fact that the most sought after Harvard Law graduate gave up offers from prestigious firms to go back and work to reclaim the neighborhoods where he grew up in Chicago not counter the specious cries of "elitist?" And even if it doesn't, haven't we learned that an elite president might just be a little more effective than "the one you'd rather have a beer with?"
Go Tribe!
(yeah, I've seen their record... this will very shortly be replaced with Go Browns!)
Luth,
Out
*look it up... although this is the original figure of speech, what McCain is doing these days is more closely described by the mistaken "towing the line." Ha, that's pretty funny!
Tuesday, July 01, 2008
Mailing List
I got this from the Ohio Republican Party in tonight's email:
Outrageous and offensive.
There’s just no other way to describe the gutter campaign tactic the Obama campaign pulled Sunday.
“I don't think riding in a fighter plane and getting shot down is a qualification to be President.” That’s what Obama spokesman Gen. Wesley Clark said Sunday on national television.
Sadly, it’s not the first time the Democrats have tried to smear John McCain’s war record, and it won’t be the last.
Will you contribute $100, $250, or $500 today to help us push back?
We’re building an Ohio defense fund to counter these insidious attacks by Sen. Obama and his supporters.
John McCain spent five years being tortured as a prisoner of war in Vietnam. His heroic service to our nation stands in stark contrast to Sen. Obama’s thin record (that doesn’t contain a single day of military duty).
Please help us fight back.
Your contribution of $100, $250, or $500 will help us build a defense fund here in Ohio so we can counter these slash and burn tactics by a candidate who promised a “new” kind of politics but delivers more of the same.
Kevin DeWine
Deputy Chairman
I don't know what's funnier... that I'm on their mailing list, or that this is considered outrageous and offensive after what the Bush administration did to Gen. Wesley Clark or what Republican Representative Saxby Chambliss did to Vietnam Vet and triple amputee, Max Cleland, or what the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth did to John Kerry or what W's DD214 did for him... oh wait, the department of defense's official records don't count for anything. (Cleland, for those of you who have forgotten this real hero already, left three major body parts in Vietnam then came home to serve as the Georgia Representative until Chambliss, who avoided duty in Vietnam with a bad knee, questioned his patriotism - QUESTIONED HIS PATRIOTISM! and got away with it to beat him for the rep seat.) To me, that kinda makes Clark's comments pretty insignificant, pretty "who gives a shit?" even if I'll admit that I may not have said it out loud myself. Seriously... outrageous and offensive? Just stop.
Before I go on, let me reiterate that I had a lot of respect for Senator McCain as much for his military service as for his bipartisan git r done-ness in the senate. He was one of few congressmen who remembered that he was elected to work for us, not sulk or smirk from one side of the aisle. He put ego and party aside and continued to debate and discuss until compromise was reached and the work got done... but that was before he underwent the transformation to become a national party figure.
NOTE: the following is true of BOTH parties: Apparently rising to the top of national party politics even castrates otherwise hardworking, common sense guys like Sen. McCain. It's sad, really. His purposeful and blatant distancing from Bush made him much more likable a year or two ago than I find him now. I truly felt that for the first time in my voting life I would experience an election that might actually turn out ok for the nation regardless of the winner as opposed to being a matter of desperately pleading on behalf of the lesser of two evils. That all changed as McCain's rhetoric changed to match that of his party. In other words, I was cool with both candidates until McCain opens his mouth lately.
Back to the Ohio Republican Party newsletter: Since Clark's comments were on behalf of the party I'm backing this year, I'll admit that I'm not real proud of what he said. I mean it's something I've always thought - it's not like McCain (or any other detainee or downed fighter pilot) tried to get shot down and become a prisoner (I hope) And how does being shot down qualify one to lead? Right? But even I wouldn't say that out loud in the context of a national campaign. Surviving what McCain did ranks right up close to the ultimate sacrifice. So I wouldn't say what Clark said to the press, from a position of prominence, during a campaign. I'd say it in a bar. In fact, I think I have, seriously... if it were a democrat wouldn't repubs say the same thing? But that don't make it right for a national figure to say publicly during the campaign.
And then there's the whole "smearing a war record" part. Hello, can you say "swift boat veterans?" But what are the Ohio Repubs worried about anyway? War record smearing only hurts Democrats. W's war record didn't even need smearing. The record itself was a smear. The fact that he couldn't even fulfill his National Guard "get of Vietnam free" pass and still got elected twice is a pretty good argument that war records of Republicans will not be considered as detrimental to their careers.
But seriously, Ohio Republican Party... outrageous and offensive? In modern campaign terms? More so than the Swift Boat Veteran ads criticizing a decorated active duty officer while a National Guard deserter gets re-elected? More so than questioning a disabled combat veteran triple amputee congressman's patriotism? Really? No, REALLY?
And how in the hell did I end up on your mailing list? Now that's outrageous! (a guy buys one semi-automatic weapon and suddenly the NRA and the Republican Party assume he'll hand over all his money!)
Luth,
Out
PS I apologize for the previous post - not the content, but the terrible writing. I just couldn't go to bed yet and had to spew something.
Outrageous and offensive.
There’s just no other way to describe the gutter campaign tactic the Obama campaign pulled Sunday.
“I don't think riding in a fighter plane and getting shot down is a qualification to be President.” That’s what Obama spokesman Gen. Wesley Clark said Sunday on national television.
Sadly, it’s not the first time the Democrats have tried to smear John McCain’s war record, and it won’t be the last.
Will you contribute $100, $250, or $500 today to help us push back?
We’re building an Ohio defense fund to counter these insidious attacks by Sen. Obama and his supporters.
John McCain spent five years being tortured as a prisoner of war in Vietnam. His heroic service to our nation stands in stark contrast to Sen. Obama’s thin record (that doesn’t contain a single day of military duty).
Please help us fight back.
Your contribution of $100, $250, or $500 will help us build a defense fund here in Ohio so we can counter these slash and burn tactics by a candidate who promised a “new” kind of politics but delivers more of the same.
Kevin DeWine
Deputy Chairman
I don't know what's funnier... that I'm on their mailing list, or that this is considered outrageous and offensive after what the Bush administration did to Gen. Wesley Clark or what Republican Representative Saxby Chambliss did to Vietnam Vet and triple amputee, Max Cleland, or what the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth did to John Kerry or what W's DD214 did for him... oh wait, the department of defense's official records don't count for anything. (Cleland, for those of you who have forgotten this real hero already, left three major body parts in Vietnam then came home to serve as the Georgia Representative until Chambliss, who avoided duty in Vietnam with a bad knee, questioned his patriotism - QUESTIONED HIS PATRIOTISM! and got away with it to beat him for the rep seat.) To me, that kinda makes Clark's comments pretty insignificant, pretty "who gives a shit?" even if I'll admit that I may not have said it out loud myself. Seriously... outrageous and offensive? Just stop.
Before I go on, let me reiterate that I had a lot of respect for Senator McCain as much for his military service as for his bipartisan git r done-ness in the senate. He was one of few congressmen who remembered that he was elected to work for us, not sulk or smirk from one side of the aisle. He put ego and party aside and continued to debate and discuss until compromise was reached and the work got done... but that was before he underwent the transformation to become a national party figure.
NOTE: the following is true of BOTH parties: Apparently rising to the top of national party politics even castrates otherwise hardworking, common sense guys like Sen. McCain. It's sad, really. His purposeful and blatant distancing from Bush made him much more likable a year or two ago than I find him now. I truly felt that for the first time in my voting life I would experience an election that might actually turn out ok for the nation regardless of the winner as opposed to being a matter of desperately pleading on behalf of the lesser of two evils. That all changed as McCain's rhetoric changed to match that of his party. In other words, I was cool with both candidates until McCain opens his mouth lately.
Back to the Ohio Republican Party newsletter: Since Clark's comments were on behalf of the party I'm backing this year, I'll admit that I'm not real proud of what he said. I mean it's something I've always thought - it's not like McCain (or any other detainee or downed fighter pilot) tried to get shot down and become a prisoner (I hope) And how does being shot down qualify one to lead? Right? But even I wouldn't say that out loud in the context of a national campaign. Surviving what McCain did ranks right up close to the ultimate sacrifice. So I wouldn't say what Clark said to the press, from a position of prominence, during a campaign. I'd say it in a bar. In fact, I think I have, seriously... if it were a democrat wouldn't repubs say the same thing? But that don't make it right for a national figure to say publicly during the campaign.
And then there's the whole "smearing a war record" part. Hello, can you say "swift boat veterans?" But what are the Ohio Repubs worried about anyway? War record smearing only hurts Democrats. W's war record didn't even need smearing. The record itself was a smear. The fact that he couldn't even fulfill his National Guard "get of Vietnam free" pass and still got elected twice is a pretty good argument that war records of Republicans will not be considered as detrimental to their careers.
But seriously, Ohio Republican Party... outrageous and offensive? In modern campaign terms? More so than the Swift Boat Veteran ads criticizing a decorated active duty officer while a National Guard deserter gets re-elected? More so than questioning a disabled combat veteran triple amputee congressman's patriotism? Really? No, REALLY?
And how in the hell did I end up on your mailing list? Now that's outrageous! (a guy buys one semi-automatic weapon and suddenly the NRA and the Republican Party assume he'll hand over all his money!)
Luth,
Out
PS I apologize for the previous post - not the content, but the terrible writing. I just couldn't go to bed yet and had to spew something.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)