Even if the title of this post were true, is that such a bad thing?
Some folks whose opinions I generally value mentioned they were a little leery of Barack Obama because he, their words, not mine, “came out of nowhere.” Another person, whom I don’t know as well, but generally have pretty good regard for, added that Glenn Beck had been running commercials calling Obama the anti-Christ for this very reason. As though Obama’s amazingly rapid rise could only be the result of some supernatural intervention.
Since I’m still, perhaps naively, excited about the prospect of a President Obama, this concerned me. These folks, while perhaps a little more educated than the general population, are as Joe-beercan as the people I know get. I thought about their words the whole way home from National Guard duty last weekend.
I put it out of my mind for a while, but the other afternoon, while waiting for my daughter to find out that she needs new glasses (along with orthodonture and a new wardrobe, especially shoes) I ran across an article in TIME comparing the experience of the top three candidates - McCain, Clinton and Obama. I wasn’t surprised to learn that Hillary and Barack are actually pretty close in actual experience. Granted, Hillary was first lady for 8 years, but as Chris Rock says, “My wife’s been married to me for as long as I’ve been a comedian, but she’s never been on stage. She’s not funny.” (or something like that) Take away those eight years in the White House, and they're actually pretty close.
So when it comes to actual experience, though some of Obama’s was only at the state level, he may not be fully loaded, but he definitely didn't come from nowhere. I guess what strikes me most about learning this, rather than just having a vague idea about it, is that his political experience places him well ahead of our current president. Let alone the successful business ventures Obama has been a part of, just one of which places him well ahead of our current president, but hey, it's too late to worry about that, and as I've made obnoxiously clear, I didn't vote for the guy. Back to Obama... if elected in 2008, he'd be the 19th (out of 43) most experienced president we've elected, according to an article in THE ST. PETERSBURG TIMES.
To complicate the issue even more, the TIME article covered the idea that experience isn’t a magic bullet. Kennedy, Lincoln and both Roosevelts had relatively limited political experience. Kennedy even cited his lack of it in his confession of mishandling the Bay of Pigs invasion. Yet each of these candidates was fairly well received and remembered. Along the same confusing lines, each of them faced situations for which no amount of experience could have prepared them.
On the other hand, many of our worst presidents, Nixon, Ohio's own Warren Harding (who even admits he was a bad president) had tons of experience, which, in each of their cases, turned out to be called patronage from another perspective. Add the current discussions about super delegates whose job it was, at one point at least, to prevent such patronage-styled ascendancies, and you’ve got a million questions to answer before you can cast a semi-intelligent vote. Good luck with that!
It's sad for me now that the Republican party has capitulated to its weak slate. For a while there, I was really thinking that for the first time in my voting life, a Romney vs. Obama ticket would actually provide two good choices rather than the lesser of two evils. Yes, I joked about Ron Paul, and seriously like some of his ideas, but he's crazy. Although, I have to admit, I'd probably go ahead and toss my vote their way if he teamed up with Ralph Nader!
As far as the Dems go, I concede that Hillary seems to be a very capable politician with whom I agree on several of the bigger issues, but my decision was made a while back when Romney and Obama emerged as the only contenders who did NOT cast a vote in favor of the war in Iraq. Granted, Romney, as governor of Massachusetts, didn't get the chance to do so, but that was good enough for me at that point. Still is. And that's the issue that pushes Obama far ahead of Hillary for me.
I admire John McCain. He's one of few senators who has routinely put partisanship aside and hammered out compromises and solved tough fights in the senate. I appreciate his service to the country as a service member and as a senator, but his war vote and his strange support of the president who conned us into it are the deal breaker there. I just can't figure him out and I'm not willing to gamble given the recent past.
Obama, on the other hand, may have limited political experience, but that's one of his most endearing qualities given the past 25 years worth of presidents. I like the guy like I like what I've learned about Bobby Kennedy. He's an idealist with the charisma to get things done. Some of those same people mentioned at the start of this post fear that people like their backwoods friends might shoot Obama because of the color of his skin were he elected, and we'd have to start over again, but I'm going to give today's secret service more credit than that. Granted, it's hard to stop a mad man even if the madness stems from psychotic ignorance, but I think we're a little better at those kinds of things these days... and I think, again, perhaps naively, that those secret societies who may have perpetrated such an attempt in the past have suffered a bit of a brain drain over the years. I'll put my money on the secret service getting better enough to take them.
Anyhoo, let's all put our collective brain power into staying out of Iran now that Bush has driven out William Fallon... yet another respected-across-the-board expert (who fought against invading Iran) to leave this highly praised administration.
Oh, and at some point, we've got to continue to discuss mankind's developments on the religious front. I'll leave you with this unoriginal thought:
The Greeks and Romans marked a great leap forward in reason when they reduced the number of gods they worshipped from many to one. We're poised to leave as our legacy the final chapter in the age of reason by continuing that trend if only we can reduce the number one more time!
Luth
Out
The weekly, OK, monthly, OK quarterly ramblings of a regular guy with a mildly liberal bent, who is sick of BOTH parties and their BS. For those of you just joining us, click on the March 2005 archive, scroll to the bottom of the posts, and read your way back up... or at least read that first one to see how this mess got started out of fear and boredom in Iraq.
Tuesday, March 18, 2008
Monday, January 14, 2008
Colts, Titans get what they deserve
Before I even start, let me clarify that I'm among the many Browns fans who believe the Browns sealed their OWN fate this year by losing a winnable game to the Bengals. I do NOT believe the Colts owed them anything, nor am I bitter because the Colts kept the Browns out of the playoffs. The be clear, the Browns kept the Browns out of the playoffs and though the taste was on the tip of our tongues this year, I'll take a 10 and 6 season as a giant step in the right direction and wait happily for next season as I am so accustomed to doing as a fan of Cleveland sports all my life. The following rant has nothing to do with that.
Now it's time. Tennessee and Indy got exactly what they deserved this week. After all, they quit playing professional football THREE weeks ago! While the Giants and the Patriots left it all out on the field during their last regular season game, with absolutely NOTHNG to gain from it, the Colts and the Titans seemed to forget that they were millionaire professional athletes whose sole purpose on game day is to entertain fans. I don't know about you, but I rarely find watching towels being thrown in entertaining, although in this case, had the throwing of towels been literal perhaps it would have been more entertaining than the actual end of that game!
In the case of the Giants, their end of season effort clearly propelled them over Dallas last night. Coming off of a serious threat to topple the great Patriot dynasty, they pulled off a huge playoff win. The NY defense had no business holding Dallas to only 17 points and hanging the hopes for a playoff game on special teams and a hit or miss offense is not exactly a safe bet. But the Giants learned how important showing up for the end of season games can be. They came out ready, not as thoroughly rested as I'm guessing the Titans and the Colts hoped to be, and pulled it off. So Eli will be playing while Peyton watches... just like Peyton did for the second half of the last regular season game. Apparently he likes to watch. Good for him. He's got the entire off season to do it now. He, his teammates, and the Titans deserve it.
I had to get that out of my system.
Luth
Now it's time. Tennessee and Indy got exactly what they deserved this week. After all, they quit playing professional football THREE weeks ago! While the Giants and the Patriots left it all out on the field during their last regular season game, with absolutely NOTHNG to gain from it, the Colts and the Titans seemed to forget that they were millionaire professional athletes whose sole purpose on game day is to entertain fans. I don't know about you, but I rarely find watching towels being thrown in entertaining, although in this case, had the throwing of towels been literal perhaps it would have been more entertaining than the actual end of that game!
In the case of the Giants, their end of season effort clearly propelled them over Dallas last night. Coming off of a serious threat to topple the great Patriot dynasty, they pulled off a huge playoff win. The NY defense had no business holding Dallas to only 17 points and hanging the hopes for a playoff game on special teams and a hit or miss offense is not exactly a safe bet. But the Giants learned how important showing up for the end of season games can be. They came out ready, not as thoroughly rested as I'm guessing the Titans and the Colts hoped to be, and pulled it off. So Eli will be playing while Peyton watches... just like Peyton did for the second half of the last regular season game. Apparently he likes to watch. Good for him. He's got the entire off season to do it now. He, his teammates, and the Titans deserve it.
I had to get that out of my system.
Luth
Wednesday, January 09, 2008
Led Zeppelin and the source of all knowledge
Boy did I ever miss that call about the BCS Championship! Not only did I not celebrate a victory, I didn’t even see most of the last half. That roughing the kicker penalty in the first drive of the second half was all I could stand. Ah well, as a northern Ohio football fan through and through, I’m not stranger to these words: next season.
I just got back from dropping off a neighbor girl who was hanging out with my daughters tonight. On the way there, the opening notes of Stairway to Heaven caught my ears as I scanned the local radio stations. I don’t know if it’s because I recently read the Rolling Stone article about the band’s London reunion/fundraiser and that planted some kind of seed or if it’s because my LPs have been in a box for about 15 years, but I was compelled to drive around the block a couple of times to hear the whole song, gradually turning up the volume until we pulled in the driveway just in time to hear Robert Plant’s final pleading cry.
I haven’t WANTED to listen to a Led Zeppelin song in a long time, but for some reason, it sounded pretty darned good tonight. In fact, I might dig out the one Zep CD I have just to make sure it wasn’t a fluke.
For a long time I’ve pulled a random CD off the rack and tossed it in my truck just to listen to something I haven’t heard in a while, but the closest to classic rock I’ve listened to was maybe The Clash or The Kinks. The desire to grab something like Aerosmith or AC DC just went away like my childhood love of macaroni and cheese after living on it through the college years.
Now that I think about it, the mac and cheese jones came back for a while too after my kids started liking it… peanut butter and jelly kind of worked that way too. Until I’d made both for my kids, I probably went close to a decade without even considering eating either of those two delicacies. I wonder if that’s why fashion trends always come back around too. One of the surest signs that something will come back is when some expert says it won’t.
When it comes to my musical likes and dislikes, I suppose I’m the expert, and I know classic rock suffered some dark days (in the case of my taste) after its resurgence on FM radio throughout my high school and college days. By then, most of my friends and I had just about had our fill and were really waiting for the next big thing to happen in rock music. About the time the radio stations decided for us that there was no new rock music worth listening to, we had grown weary of the 1000th playing of Freebird, Stairway and Light My Fire. I’m sure we weren’t alone, but the radio offered little in the way of hope, until, alas, musicians forced their hand, but radio, in its hubris, couldn’t admit that rock lived on and had to call the latest wave of new rock, “alternative,” and at that moment true rock and roll finally belched forth its death rattle.
Sure the hair bands gave it their all. Techno-punk like Akron’s own Devo and a few other strange oddities of the 80’s didn’t exactly force radio to admit they might have been wrong about forcing 20 year old songs down our ears rather than rolling with the changes, but that was pretty much it for the evolution of rock and roll. If any new rock music existed, from that moment forward it had to call itself alternative.
I’m not sure why this is pouring out of me tonight… I guess I just had to share the Stairway story ‘cuz it really did sound good. And not in some longing for the old days way, but just good, like rain on the roof as you lay in bed or a harmonica crying through a valley. No memory was necessarily associated with it. It was just a cool song again… after years of switching to the CD player or hitting search on the tuner when one of those classic songs came on in the past.
As I type this it occurs to me that this is somehow twisted up in a recurring thought I’ve been coming back to lately. It’s the result of the many debates, discussions and even arguments I had while a graduate student of rhetoric: where does knowledge come from? The specific version of this for students of rhetoric is, are words the source of/creators of knowledge, or do words form later out of necessity to describe a pre-existing truth that’s just “out there?”
Fashion trends obviously are influenced by culture and society, but I don’t know if I can buy that about my musical tastes. I mean, I’m sure culture and society are a small factor, but can that really explain why a song I used to like, but grew tired of suddenly catches me in the right moment? The station that played it has probably played it another thousand times since I stopped listening to it habitually. I’ll tune in to it every now and then to see what’s on, but generally skip past after hearing one of the same hundred or so songs.
So how does this get back to the epistemological question? I’m not sure exactly, but I can’t help but think it does. Do the words that describe fashion trends cause those trends to come back? I think they do in some ways. Maybe not just the words, but talking about the trend more surely must. Malcolm Gladwell’s The Tipping Point covers some tangent of this by describing the “cool” people who started wearing Hush Puppies again just as the company considered calling it quits, but unless the rest of us started talking about those cool people, their choice in footwear would have had little effect on the rest of us and no effect on the company or foot fashion trends.
I also can’t help but think this concept fits squarely with the previous few posts… ok, maybe not squarely, but tangentially. When it comes to religious faith, the source of knowledge is clearly at the root of the issue. I’ll contend that our socio-cultural-political climate of late wouldn’t even allow me to discuss this with anyone outside of a college lounge, not classroom. Even academia’s quest to go overboard about being objective has them backpedaling from their previously infamous criticism of religion in the classroom. (much like modern media and its former liberal bias) But in the context of my last posts, I’ll risk saying it here: I believe man is the source of the knowledge we take from the Bible. The fact that man has written it and translated it through several languages over the last thousand or so years is beyond question, but where man got those ideas seems to be the real issue. So there we are again back at do words create knowledge or do we create words to describe knowledge that exists on its own?
In my quest to find answers that satisfy me to questions like this, I wandered through a few other books that some think need a capital B. Lao Tzu’s The Way, English versions of the Koran, a number of books on variations of Eastern philosophy (I still dig those) and various stages of Bible study from the traditional K-8 indoctrination leading to confirmation in a United Church of Christ to courses on the Bible as Literature as an undergrad, and studies of a handful of saints and other Christian figures as rhetoricians. The one thing the religions I’ve glanced at have in common is that they all claim the source of knowledge was divine. It was “out there.” We only use words to describe and discuss it, not create it.
Obviously, my current thinking about that is beyond skepticism, but as I sit back and take an inventory, I’m even more convinced, but maybe for a different reason. After all, is there really a difference between saying man (through his words) creates knowledge vs. knowledge was given to man by God, but then that knowledge had to be shared with his fellow man through man’s word? Either way, man creates, alters, adjusts, tweeks and otherwise makes what he wants out of that knowledge. Maybe that’s why so many people think rhetoricians are strange, because what we argue about doesn’t really matter.
But that only solves the problem for folks who believe God is the source of all knowledge. There are plenty of folks out there who disagree and thus still struggle with epistemology. I think I’m joining them because when it comes to what form that knowledge takes, and, more importantly, which God created it, the books just don’t jive. I mean, if Allah (pbuh) is the source, then Christians have really strayed from that path, and of course, like the Christian path, Allah’s (pbuh) was divinely delivered so there’s no questioning it. In fact, the Bible foreshadows Mohamed and the Koran refers back to the Bible. Somewhere in there some signals must have gotten crossed… then again, we only have man’s interpretations of both.
That’s about all I can take right now and I’ve got a new Chuck Palahniuk book I can’t wait to dig in to, so that’s it for now.
Luth
Out
I just got back from dropping off a neighbor girl who was hanging out with my daughters tonight. On the way there, the opening notes of Stairway to Heaven caught my ears as I scanned the local radio stations. I don’t know if it’s because I recently read the Rolling Stone article about the band’s London reunion/fundraiser and that planted some kind of seed or if it’s because my LPs have been in a box for about 15 years, but I was compelled to drive around the block a couple of times to hear the whole song, gradually turning up the volume until we pulled in the driveway just in time to hear Robert Plant’s final pleading cry.
I haven’t WANTED to listen to a Led Zeppelin song in a long time, but for some reason, it sounded pretty darned good tonight. In fact, I might dig out the one Zep CD I have just to make sure it wasn’t a fluke.
For a long time I’ve pulled a random CD off the rack and tossed it in my truck just to listen to something I haven’t heard in a while, but the closest to classic rock I’ve listened to was maybe The Clash or The Kinks. The desire to grab something like Aerosmith or AC DC just went away like my childhood love of macaroni and cheese after living on it through the college years.
Now that I think about it, the mac and cheese jones came back for a while too after my kids started liking it… peanut butter and jelly kind of worked that way too. Until I’d made both for my kids, I probably went close to a decade without even considering eating either of those two delicacies. I wonder if that’s why fashion trends always come back around too. One of the surest signs that something will come back is when some expert says it won’t.
When it comes to my musical likes and dislikes, I suppose I’m the expert, and I know classic rock suffered some dark days (in the case of my taste) after its resurgence on FM radio throughout my high school and college days. By then, most of my friends and I had just about had our fill and were really waiting for the next big thing to happen in rock music. About the time the radio stations decided for us that there was no new rock music worth listening to, we had grown weary of the 1000th playing of Freebird, Stairway and Light My Fire. I’m sure we weren’t alone, but the radio offered little in the way of hope, until, alas, musicians forced their hand, but radio, in its hubris, couldn’t admit that rock lived on and had to call the latest wave of new rock, “alternative,” and at that moment true rock and roll finally belched forth its death rattle.
Sure the hair bands gave it their all. Techno-punk like Akron’s own Devo and a few other strange oddities of the 80’s didn’t exactly force radio to admit they might have been wrong about forcing 20 year old songs down our ears rather than rolling with the changes, but that was pretty much it for the evolution of rock and roll. If any new rock music existed, from that moment forward it had to call itself alternative.
I’m not sure why this is pouring out of me tonight… I guess I just had to share the Stairway story ‘cuz it really did sound good. And not in some longing for the old days way, but just good, like rain on the roof as you lay in bed or a harmonica crying through a valley. No memory was necessarily associated with it. It was just a cool song again… after years of switching to the CD player or hitting search on the tuner when one of those classic songs came on in the past.
As I type this it occurs to me that this is somehow twisted up in a recurring thought I’ve been coming back to lately. It’s the result of the many debates, discussions and even arguments I had while a graduate student of rhetoric: where does knowledge come from? The specific version of this for students of rhetoric is, are words the source of/creators of knowledge, or do words form later out of necessity to describe a pre-existing truth that’s just “out there?”
Fashion trends obviously are influenced by culture and society, but I don’t know if I can buy that about my musical tastes. I mean, I’m sure culture and society are a small factor, but can that really explain why a song I used to like, but grew tired of suddenly catches me in the right moment? The station that played it has probably played it another thousand times since I stopped listening to it habitually. I’ll tune in to it every now and then to see what’s on, but generally skip past after hearing one of the same hundred or so songs.
So how does this get back to the epistemological question? I’m not sure exactly, but I can’t help but think it does. Do the words that describe fashion trends cause those trends to come back? I think they do in some ways. Maybe not just the words, but talking about the trend more surely must. Malcolm Gladwell’s The Tipping Point covers some tangent of this by describing the “cool” people who started wearing Hush Puppies again just as the company considered calling it quits, but unless the rest of us started talking about those cool people, their choice in footwear would have had little effect on the rest of us and no effect on the company or foot fashion trends.
I also can’t help but think this concept fits squarely with the previous few posts… ok, maybe not squarely, but tangentially. When it comes to religious faith, the source of knowledge is clearly at the root of the issue. I’ll contend that our socio-cultural-political climate of late wouldn’t even allow me to discuss this with anyone outside of a college lounge, not classroom. Even academia’s quest to go overboard about being objective has them backpedaling from their previously infamous criticism of religion in the classroom. (much like modern media and its former liberal bias) But in the context of my last posts, I’ll risk saying it here: I believe man is the source of the knowledge we take from the Bible. The fact that man has written it and translated it through several languages over the last thousand or so years is beyond question, but where man got those ideas seems to be the real issue. So there we are again back at do words create knowledge or do we create words to describe knowledge that exists on its own?
In my quest to find answers that satisfy me to questions like this, I wandered through a few other books that some think need a capital B. Lao Tzu’s The Way, English versions of the Koran, a number of books on variations of Eastern philosophy (I still dig those) and various stages of Bible study from the traditional K-8 indoctrination leading to confirmation in a United Church of Christ to courses on the Bible as Literature as an undergrad, and studies of a handful of saints and other Christian figures as rhetoricians. The one thing the religions I’ve glanced at have in common is that they all claim the source of knowledge was divine. It was “out there.” We only use words to describe and discuss it, not create it.
Obviously, my current thinking about that is beyond skepticism, but as I sit back and take an inventory, I’m even more convinced, but maybe for a different reason. After all, is there really a difference between saying man (through his words) creates knowledge vs. knowledge was given to man by God, but then that knowledge had to be shared with his fellow man through man’s word? Either way, man creates, alters, adjusts, tweeks and otherwise makes what he wants out of that knowledge. Maybe that’s why so many people think rhetoricians are strange, because what we argue about doesn’t really matter.
But that only solves the problem for folks who believe God is the source of all knowledge. There are plenty of folks out there who disagree and thus still struggle with epistemology. I think I’m joining them because when it comes to what form that knowledge takes, and, more importantly, which God created it, the books just don’t jive. I mean, if Allah (pbuh) is the source, then Christians have really strayed from that path, and of course, like the Christian path, Allah’s (pbuh) was divinely delivered so there’s no questioning it. In fact, the Bible foreshadows Mohamed and the Koran refers back to the Bible. Somewhere in there some signals must have gotten crossed… then again, we only have man’s interpretations of both.
That’s about all I can take right now and I’ve got a new Chuck Palahniuk book I can’t wait to dig in to, so that’s it for now.
Luth
Out
Monday, January 07, 2008
Why those last two posts don't conflict and some other stuff.
Let's continue with our dialogue about religion. I'll start:
Prove it.
That's usually where the dialogue about religion I had in mind stops. Discuss any issue of any importance regarding any topic other than religion, and that's the standard to which we hold the other conversant. But when it comes to religion, that standard is gone.
As I've mentioned here before, when it comes to the affairs of men (and women) on this planet, that should be the standard. If you can't provide solid, empirical evidence, wrapped in a logical argument for your plan, then why should men accept it?
The answer to that last question in every case except where religion is concerned is, "they shouldn't."
That's the dialogue we should have more of.
Now let's have some fun with this...
For instance, did you hear the one about the biologist at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute who says he was fired because of his religion and is suing for a half a million? The research lab says they fired him because he refused to do the job. He even wrote that he didn't want to do it in a letter to his boss. Ok, that's a little nuanced... he didn't want to work on the "evolutionary aspects of the NIH grants" for which he was hired. He's a biologist. He studies evolution.
His lawyers argue that he was never asked if he believed in evolution when he was hired so that wasn't a job requirement and therefore it can't be used to fire him. (Wouldn't that be like asking doctor if he believes in the power of medicine? Does anyone really ask that?) His lawyer also says that believing in evolution requires as much "faith" as believing in creation.
It's true that believing in evolution requires faith, but not in the sense that the lawyer is trying to suggest by invoking the two defintions of the word. Scientific faith (not to be confused with Scientology) is the same faith required to drive on a two lane highway. You're separated by only a foot or two by oncoming traffic doing at least 55 miles per hour. If you and an oncoming driver sneeze at the wrong time, you both die. You have to have faith in that other driver's ability to not sneeze. But that kind of faith doesn't require belief in mythical beings or man's words describing what those beings think. It comes from repeated observations of other drivers on the road.
Science does in fact require that kind of faith. Faith that other researchers have done their work, that your data is solid and that the conclusions are true, repeatable under controlled conditions, etc. Faith in conclusions supported by observable evidence achieved over repeated testing is not the same as faith in a religion. The laywer knows this, but he won't point it out to the jury.
They won't have the dialogue about religion that they should. The lawyer, who knows why the biologist who refused to report on his research was fired, won't argue the merits of his case, he will argue the merits of firing someone because of his religion. He will paint the Insitute as devil-worshipping for this. The Insititute's lawyers will argue that they simply want complete reports supported by empricial evidence, but they won't dare mention that there's no empricial evidence of creation because the jury will then use the biologist's lawyer's paint brush to paint them as devil worshippers as well and the Insititue will lose their case based not on the merits of the case, but based on human insecurity and inability to look at the facts in a case involving religion.
Or here's another for instance: if I call Mike Huckabee's arrogance or campaign spending hypocritical in terms of the Christianity I studied, I can prove that with Bible verses that directly address it, but when he says abortion and same sex marriage are wrong because God says so, he can't prove that. I can provide evidence that God (if he exists) aborts more babies than anyone on Earth and I can provide evidence that the word "homosexual" is NEVER used in the Bible. But no one has shown me any evidence that God doesn't approve of or at least condone these things.
That's the kind of dialogue I'd like to have more of, but I'm never allowed. People always say, don't argue politics or religion. Or they get mad at my questions and tell me I just have to "believe."
And I do believe... what I see and what I know... and what is presented to me with evidence, in a logical argument. I also believe that there's a lot about human nature we don't know, especially when it comes to spiritual or conscious needs. I believe too that religion can provide a sense of comfort in lieu of further understanding about these needs, but that it can also prevent further understanding of these needs unless we're allowed to question it objectively as we do other biological, chemical and physical processes. Questioning it objectively means asking for proof of the answers.
Any belief beyond that should be left out of the conversation when it comes to the affairs of man. It would result in a lot less bloodshed and a lot more progress toward solving the other issues facing mankind.
I have to go watch the Buckeyes win another BCS National Championship... don't even get me started arguing about that!
Luth
Out
Prove it.
That's usually where the dialogue about religion I had in mind stops. Discuss any issue of any importance regarding any topic other than religion, and that's the standard to which we hold the other conversant. But when it comes to religion, that standard is gone.
As I've mentioned here before, when it comes to the affairs of men (and women) on this planet, that should be the standard. If you can't provide solid, empirical evidence, wrapped in a logical argument for your plan, then why should men accept it?
The answer to that last question in every case except where religion is concerned is, "they shouldn't."
That's the dialogue we should have more of.
Now let's have some fun with this...
For instance, did you hear the one about the biologist at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute who says he was fired because of his religion and is suing for a half a million? The research lab says they fired him because he refused to do the job. He even wrote that he didn't want to do it in a letter to his boss. Ok, that's a little nuanced... he didn't want to work on the "evolutionary aspects of the NIH grants" for which he was hired. He's a biologist. He studies evolution.
His lawyers argue that he was never asked if he believed in evolution when he was hired so that wasn't a job requirement and therefore it can't be used to fire him. (Wouldn't that be like asking doctor if he believes in the power of medicine? Does anyone really ask that?) His lawyer also says that believing in evolution requires as much "faith" as believing in creation.
It's true that believing in evolution requires faith, but not in the sense that the lawyer is trying to suggest by invoking the two defintions of the word. Scientific faith (not to be confused with Scientology) is the same faith required to drive on a two lane highway. You're separated by only a foot or two by oncoming traffic doing at least 55 miles per hour. If you and an oncoming driver sneeze at the wrong time, you both die. You have to have faith in that other driver's ability to not sneeze. But that kind of faith doesn't require belief in mythical beings or man's words describing what those beings think. It comes from repeated observations of other drivers on the road.
Science does in fact require that kind of faith. Faith that other researchers have done their work, that your data is solid and that the conclusions are true, repeatable under controlled conditions, etc. Faith in conclusions supported by observable evidence achieved over repeated testing is not the same as faith in a religion. The laywer knows this, but he won't point it out to the jury.
They won't have the dialogue about religion that they should. The lawyer, who knows why the biologist who refused to report on his research was fired, won't argue the merits of his case, he will argue the merits of firing someone because of his religion. He will paint the Insitute as devil-worshipping for this. The Insititute's lawyers will argue that they simply want complete reports supported by empricial evidence, but they won't dare mention that there's no empricial evidence of creation because the jury will then use the biologist's lawyer's paint brush to paint them as devil worshippers as well and the Insititue will lose their case based not on the merits of the case, but based on human insecurity and inability to look at the facts in a case involving religion.
Or here's another for instance: if I call Mike Huckabee's arrogance or campaign spending hypocritical in terms of the Christianity I studied, I can prove that with Bible verses that directly address it, but when he says abortion and same sex marriage are wrong because God says so, he can't prove that. I can provide evidence that God (if he exists) aborts more babies than anyone on Earth and I can provide evidence that the word "homosexual" is NEVER used in the Bible. But no one has shown me any evidence that God doesn't approve of or at least condone these things.
That's the kind of dialogue I'd like to have more of, but I'm never allowed. People always say, don't argue politics or religion. Or they get mad at my questions and tell me I just have to "believe."
And I do believe... what I see and what I know... and what is presented to me with evidence, in a logical argument. I also believe that there's a lot about human nature we don't know, especially when it comes to spiritual or conscious needs. I believe too that religion can provide a sense of comfort in lieu of further understanding about these needs, but that it can also prevent further understanding of these needs unless we're allowed to question it objectively as we do other biological, chemical and physical processes. Questioning it objectively means asking for proof of the answers.
Any belief beyond that should be left out of the conversation when it comes to the affairs of man. It would result in a lot less bloodshed and a lot more progress toward solving the other issues facing mankind.
I have to go watch the Buckeyes win another BCS National Championship... don't even get me started arguing about that!
Luth
Out
Sunday, December 23, 2007
Look it up!
In the age of the internet, or maybe, more specifically, search engines, there's simply no reason to argue over the kinds of things that people used to argue over in bars, at parties, or even at the water cooler at work. Very few of these arguments exist these days that can't be solved in the two minutes it takes to Google the issue at hand. That's kind of sad really. It means that the basis of some of the more entertaining conversations in life has been removed. Unless, of course, you enjoy arguing simply for argument's sake. Which I do. After all, sometimes it's not about the answer, but what you learn in getting to it.
One perspective on this is something I used to share with my high school students during the course of our conversations about research. They would complain about the number of sources I required on a given project. I would counter the complaint with something that's eternally effective along the lines of, "WHEN I WAS A KID we had to schedule our research activities around the times when the library was actually open. We had to use actual books, magazines, journals and we had to lug them around with us because we had to actually read them to find what we wanted. All YOU have to do these days is plug something into Google, anytime, anywhere there's a computer! So quit your whining!"
The goal of the research project from the teacher's perspective was to create a situation wherein the student found a topic so interesting that they forgot about getting the project done and actually wanted to learn something about the topic. In purist terms, that's the goal of any real research... learning about the topic as opposed to proving your thesis. That makes the internet a double-edged sword. While it's true that we can find everything about a topic much easier these days, that means it's also easier to zero in on the information that suits our purpose while ignoring all information to the contrary. Because of the ease of access to lots of information, we're more tempted to believe that our research is actually thorough and conclusive simply by the sheer volume of information we can easily find that proves our thesis, even if we found it by ignoring all the other information out there. That's not a new issue, it's just that this new method of information gathering makes it easier to accept our thesis by making it easier to grab a lot of info and easier to ignore info that doesn't suit our purpose.
It's kind of the same thing with arguing in bars, parties or at the watercooler these days. There's really no point in doing it. Instead of arguing over whether or not Kevin Bacon was really in that movie with that girl from another movie, we can just call up the Internet Movie Database and look it up. Of course, by doing that, we eliminate the conversation about every other movie we liked and disliked. We eliminate the, "Oh yeah, I almost forgot about that one... that was a GREAT movie! I'm going to have to rent that one again this weekend." We also eliminate the chances of learning more about our co-workers involved with us in the discussion.
It's in the argument that the real learning takes place. When we skip straight to the answer, we lose a lot of valuable information. My daughter had a math problem the other night that illustrates the point beautifully. She had to arrange five eights in a way that gave her nine. (not the fraction, five over eight, but five separate eights) She couldn't use plus or minus signs. That's the kind of problem where the typical rules of math must be remembered and suspended at the same time and actual thinking must occur. It's tempting to just find an answer key and look it up, but that's not nearly as satisfying as figuring it out. We probably could have Googled the problem and found the solution, but instead, I gave her a large blank sheet of paper and a calculator and told her to try as many options as she could think of. In essence, I told her to argue the point. She proposed thesis after thesis all leading her down the "wrong path," but getting her closer each time because each attempt furthered her understanding. She finally settled on a fraction using decimals that resulted in an answer like 9.0909 or something like that and she left it at that. The next night she came home with the preferred, and now obvious answer. She knew a lot more about that answer because of all the "wrong" answers she came up with on her own the night before. I could have made her continue until she got even more frustrated than she was that previous night, but we both knew this problem was one of those bonus problems given during the week before a long holiday break that didn't really count for a grade. It counted for something much more important than a grade and she'd already accomplished that goal. She discovered something she didn't know before she entered the argument. Only by arguing, even if her premises were "wrong" did that discovery come about. The exercise wouldn't have worked, the discovery process would never have happened, if she'd gone straight for the answer.
Socrates knew the value of argument. He understood how, if done well, the discovery process was a guaranteed by-product. He even created a teaching method based on this. Both he and his method have been tarnished over time in our rush to find answers. The Socratic method of teaching is a brilliant method to encourage real discovery in students, but not when students are conditioned only to give right answers. Our fragile egos don't allow real discussion, aka argument, anymore. The movie Legally Blond even goes so far as to paint The Socratic Method as little more than a ruthless way of attacking students. Unfortunately, these days, that's all people think arguing is - attacking. We've forgotten that in a real argument, learning takes place. We visit areas of knowledge that have either been mothballed, or perhaps are actually new. We create the conditions required for seeing things from different perspectives. We learn about the topic, about each other, about ourselves.
Folks don't seem as comfortable learning things these days, especially if we don't like what we're learning. In his book, Punk Rock, Monster Movies and the Truth about Reality Zen Master, Brad Warner, notes that meditation isn't easy and you might not like what you discover. He claims that the goal of doing it is self awareness and he jokes that most people abandon the mission as soon as any real awareness begins because we don't like what we become aware of.
I wonder if this same fear of awareness is at the root of the old rule, "never argue politics or religion." After all, in this age of the internet, there's really no need to argue anything. We can just look it up anytime, anywhere. Unless, of course, the purpose of the arguing isn't really to find THE answer, but rather to discover something... to gain more awareness, to learn, whether what we learn is about ourselves or the others in the argument.
Could it be that this rule protects us from ever discovering anything? After all, if we can just look up any information we want, then why bother discussing anything with anyone, ever? We can just go with the answers we know are out there and never have to worry about how others see it. For that matter, these answers existed long before the internet made them more readily available to us. With a little effort, we could have found them before computers ever existed. So why argue anything? Why discuss anything? Why have a conversation with other humans, ever?
Wow, that's a pretty bleak existence.
It's also the kind of existence created by the "tolerance" of things we're too polite to discuss. When we move anything off the table of discussion, as we have the topic of religious beliefs in this country under the guise of tolerance, we create a dead zone of discussion where no further discovery can take place. By agreeing to disagree about an issue and agreeing to never discuss it, we shut ourselves off to ever discovering any more about it. By claiming we know the answers, whether because we've looked them up in a book, or in a search engine, or whatever the source, we shut ourselves off from ever discovering any more about that topic - whether that discovery leads to moving others in our direction, or us moving in their direction, or - in my naive mind still blissfully tied to the idea of way too much faith in my fellow man - a mutual discovery in both parties.
Just as with my students and their research project, finding the answers isn't ever really the goal. Discovery is. These days, I'd like to discover a formula for existence on this Earth that leads to world peace. (I admit I'm naive and have way too much faith in my fellow man, but why not... I'm here, I might as well forward this arrogant agenda of mine) When I discuss this crazy idea with a lot people, they tell me it's not worth talking about. I'm used to that and I've discussed things that truly weren't worth talking about, at length, just to kill time, so I don't let that stop me. But what really frightens me is when people tell me, "it doesn't matter anyway because the world will end in apocalypse no matter what we do."
That bothers me because it's a cop out. In a world where we can "know" everything just by looking it up, it really burns me up when someone uses that "knowledge" as an excuse to do nothing. Maybe I'm way wrong about this and maybe the world really will end in an apocalypse over which we humans have no control whatsoever, but as long as the possibility of grandkids is a twinkle in my brain, I'm going to bring it up over and over and over. I may not be able to stave off this apocalypse (although I have a suspicion that we can) but I can at least push it back until my grandkids are out of the picture. I'd like to push it back until their grandkids are out of the picture. I'd like to think this crazy idea of humans living peacefully together is one of those things that all humans agree is worth arguing about even if the argument is, at times, uncomfortable.
I don't know much for sure about this world, but I know I want it to be a peaceful place for my kids to grow up, get old, and have these same kinds of amazingly satisfying discussions with their friends, enemies, and even their own kids. And I know that the answer to how this might happen isn't in a book or on the internet. The answer, if there is one, isn't something anyone can look up. It will only ever exist in the discussions and interactions among people. While there may be predictions in books about how our world will end, one way to guarantee such an end lies firmly in the refusal to discuss it.
I don't consider that refusal polite nor tolerant.
Happy Holidays,
Luth
Oh, and congrats on the rock, Laurie Doll!
One perspective on this is something I used to share with my high school students during the course of our conversations about research. They would complain about the number of sources I required on a given project. I would counter the complaint with something that's eternally effective along the lines of, "WHEN I WAS A KID we had to schedule our research activities around the times when the library was actually open. We had to use actual books, magazines, journals and we had to lug them around with us because we had to actually read them to find what we wanted. All YOU have to do these days is plug something into Google, anytime, anywhere there's a computer! So quit your whining!"
The goal of the research project from the teacher's perspective was to create a situation wherein the student found a topic so interesting that they forgot about getting the project done and actually wanted to learn something about the topic. In purist terms, that's the goal of any real research... learning about the topic as opposed to proving your thesis. That makes the internet a double-edged sword. While it's true that we can find everything about a topic much easier these days, that means it's also easier to zero in on the information that suits our purpose while ignoring all information to the contrary. Because of the ease of access to lots of information, we're more tempted to believe that our research is actually thorough and conclusive simply by the sheer volume of information we can easily find that proves our thesis, even if we found it by ignoring all the other information out there. That's not a new issue, it's just that this new method of information gathering makes it easier to accept our thesis by making it easier to grab a lot of info and easier to ignore info that doesn't suit our purpose.
It's kind of the same thing with arguing in bars, parties or at the watercooler these days. There's really no point in doing it. Instead of arguing over whether or not Kevin Bacon was really in that movie with that girl from another movie, we can just call up the Internet Movie Database and look it up. Of course, by doing that, we eliminate the conversation about every other movie we liked and disliked. We eliminate the, "Oh yeah, I almost forgot about that one... that was a GREAT movie! I'm going to have to rent that one again this weekend." We also eliminate the chances of learning more about our co-workers involved with us in the discussion.
It's in the argument that the real learning takes place. When we skip straight to the answer, we lose a lot of valuable information. My daughter had a math problem the other night that illustrates the point beautifully. She had to arrange five eights in a way that gave her nine. (not the fraction, five over eight, but five separate eights) She couldn't use plus or minus signs. That's the kind of problem where the typical rules of math must be remembered and suspended at the same time and actual thinking must occur. It's tempting to just find an answer key and look it up, but that's not nearly as satisfying as figuring it out. We probably could have Googled the problem and found the solution, but instead, I gave her a large blank sheet of paper and a calculator and told her to try as many options as she could think of. In essence, I told her to argue the point. She proposed thesis after thesis all leading her down the "wrong path," but getting her closer each time because each attempt furthered her understanding. She finally settled on a fraction using decimals that resulted in an answer like 9.0909 or something like that and she left it at that. The next night she came home with the preferred, and now obvious answer. She knew a lot more about that answer because of all the "wrong" answers she came up with on her own the night before. I could have made her continue until she got even more frustrated than she was that previous night, but we both knew this problem was one of those bonus problems given during the week before a long holiday break that didn't really count for a grade. It counted for something much more important than a grade and she'd already accomplished that goal. She discovered something she didn't know before she entered the argument. Only by arguing, even if her premises were "wrong" did that discovery come about. The exercise wouldn't have worked, the discovery process would never have happened, if she'd gone straight for the answer.
Socrates knew the value of argument. He understood how, if done well, the discovery process was a guaranteed by-product. He even created a teaching method based on this. Both he and his method have been tarnished over time in our rush to find answers. The Socratic method of teaching is a brilliant method to encourage real discovery in students, but not when students are conditioned only to give right answers. Our fragile egos don't allow real discussion, aka argument, anymore. The movie Legally Blond even goes so far as to paint The Socratic Method as little more than a ruthless way of attacking students. Unfortunately, these days, that's all people think arguing is - attacking. We've forgotten that in a real argument, learning takes place. We visit areas of knowledge that have either been mothballed, or perhaps are actually new. We create the conditions required for seeing things from different perspectives. We learn about the topic, about each other, about ourselves.
Folks don't seem as comfortable learning things these days, especially if we don't like what we're learning. In his book, Punk Rock, Monster Movies and the Truth about Reality Zen Master, Brad Warner, notes that meditation isn't easy and you might not like what you discover. He claims that the goal of doing it is self awareness and he jokes that most people abandon the mission as soon as any real awareness begins because we don't like what we become aware of.
I wonder if this same fear of awareness is at the root of the old rule, "never argue politics or religion." After all, in this age of the internet, there's really no need to argue anything. We can just look it up anytime, anywhere. Unless, of course, the purpose of the arguing isn't really to find THE answer, but rather to discover something... to gain more awareness, to learn, whether what we learn is about ourselves or the others in the argument.
Could it be that this rule protects us from ever discovering anything? After all, if we can just look up any information we want, then why bother discussing anything with anyone, ever? We can just go with the answers we know are out there and never have to worry about how others see it. For that matter, these answers existed long before the internet made them more readily available to us. With a little effort, we could have found them before computers ever existed. So why argue anything? Why discuss anything? Why have a conversation with other humans, ever?
Wow, that's a pretty bleak existence.
It's also the kind of existence created by the "tolerance" of things we're too polite to discuss. When we move anything off the table of discussion, as we have the topic of religious beliefs in this country under the guise of tolerance, we create a dead zone of discussion where no further discovery can take place. By agreeing to disagree about an issue and agreeing to never discuss it, we shut ourselves off to ever discovering any more about it. By claiming we know the answers, whether because we've looked them up in a book, or in a search engine, or whatever the source, we shut ourselves off from ever discovering any more about that topic - whether that discovery leads to moving others in our direction, or us moving in their direction, or - in my naive mind still blissfully tied to the idea of way too much faith in my fellow man - a mutual discovery in both parties.
Just as with my students and their research project, finding the answers isn't ever really the goal. Discovery is. These days, I'd like to discover a formula for existence on this Earth that leads to world peace. (I admit I'm naive and have way too much faith in my fellow man, but why not... I'm here, I might as well forward this arrogant agenda of mine) When I discuss this crazy idea with a lot people, they tell me it's not worth talking about. I'm used to that and I've discussed things that truly weren't worth talking about, at length, just to kill time, so I don't let that stop me. But what really frightens me is when people tell me, "it doesn't matter anyway because the world will end in apocalypse no matter what we do."
That bothers me because it's a cop out. In a world where we can "know" everything just by looking it up, it really burns me up when someone uses that "knowledge" as an excuse to do nothing. Maybe I'm way wrong about this and maybe the world really will end in an apocalypse over which we humans have no control whatsoever, but as long as the possibility of grandkids is a twinkle in my brain, I'm going to bring it up over and over and over. I may not be able to stave off this apocalypse (although I have a suspicion that we can) but I can at least push it back until my grandkids are out of the picture. I'd like to push it back until their grandkids are out of the picture. I'd like to think this crazy idea of humans living peacefully together is one of those things that all humans agree is worth arguing about even if the argument is, at times, uncomfortable.
I don't know much for sure about this world, but I know I want it to be a peaceful place for my kids to grow up, get old, and have these same kinds of amazingly satisfying discussions with their friends, enemies, and even their own kids. And I know that the answer to how this might happen isn't in a book or on the internet. The answer, if there is one, isn't something anyone can look up. It will only ever exist in the discussions and interactions among people. While there may be predictions in books about how our world will end, one way to guarantee such an end lies firmly in the refusal to discuss it.
I don't consider that refusal polite nor tolerant.
Happy Holidays,
Luth
Oh, and congrats on the rock, Laurie Doll!
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
I think I could vote for Dr. Paul
If you haven't watched the You Tube/CNN debates, you've missed out. Unlike most debates, the questions come from folks like me and you. No softballs, no audience plants. In fact, the last question asked was to Rudy Giuliani about how, as a Yankees fan, he could root for the Red Sox in the Series. (His answer satisfied me - he rooted for the American League, as I did, after the Yankees were disqualified) While we're on that topic, let me get this out of my system: The curse is over and so is my empathy for Red Sox fans. The Red Sox now occupy the bottom spot on my list, forcing the Yankees up one notch.
But on to more pressing issues. Tonight's debate cleared some things up for me. Namely, Ron Paul is the only presidential candidate the Republicans could field that I'd even think about voting for. They won't field him, and, so, I won't vote Republican. Glad that's cleared up. I didn't know much about Romney or Hunter and I was curious to learn about them. I did. They're dead to me now.
Giuliani was on my list until tonight. And to his credit, he stayed there for most of the night, until he answered two questions. One was about why blacks and latinos don't vote for Republicans. Giuliani's answer indicated that they should because of what Republicans want to do with education in America. I always knew there was something I didn't like about this guy, and his answer clarified it for me. I agreed with his stance on most issues up to that point. I like reasonable gun laws. I like the fact that he doesn't really see abortion as a presidential issue, but still feels there are circumstances under which it should be legal. I like his focus on the issues at hand - crime when he was mayor, long term investments in infrastructure, and getting things done. I like a lot of things about POLITICAL (not religious) conservativism. He's a pretty good guy among his group.
But when he forced the issue of school vouchers and the non-existent alternatives to public education for the vast majority of Americans, thus pulling even more money out of an already bankrupt public education system, he lost me. This is one issue that not only affects the daily lives of many innocent Americans, but also dramatically affects our future. Public education is the best thing there is for 5-18 year olds in this country. In spite of the whining we hear from Republican candidates about how businesses have had to do more with less and therefore, government should too, both big business and government have gotten richer and richer while public schools, and the Americans who have depended on them have gotten poorer and poorer. Not only have schools still managed to gather intelligent, dedicated, creative and caring professionals at embarrassing wages to teach our kids, there is still simply no better alternative out there. Charter schools routinely close after a few years either because of corruption or because they simply can't provide the services that public schools provide for the money. Private schools exist in such small numbers that they're not even a consideration for even 10% of today's students. Even the handful of minorly successful charter ventures out there exist only for specific audiences by offering one-size-fits-all programs for narrowly targeted groups. There's just nothing better out there for the masses than public schools. And that's not because it's impossible to do, it's because public schools, by and large, are that good. No one can do what public schools do for the money. Teachers already work for embarrassing wages with embarrassing support and the Republican answer is to pull another $5000 per student OUT of that system for vouchers?! To subsidize religious schools or charter programs that haven't kept up?! It's simply not the answer. If, for one minute, America considered putting their money where their mouth is on education in this country, we'd realize that government really is good at some things. Public schools are a good example of that in education just as the Veterans Health Administration is a good example of that in health care. (In spite of CNN's week long attack on VA, it remains the best plan in America... for the record, it was even better before Bush repealed Clinton's Veteran's Healthcare Reform Act forcing VA to bring back the old WWII priority system for who received care - but that's another post) Ask Harvard... ask the NIH... nobody beats VHA health care. When we put some faith, some community involvement, and some money back into public education, no one will beat them. Few do now. Public schools are the living breathing example of doing more with less and all they have to show for it is more and more of the blame when every bit of accountability from parenting to counseling to babysitting is pushed onto them and more and more money is taken away. Never mind the fact that kids with special needs are simply not profitable to teach and so would become impossible to find a place for in the "open education market." Never mind the fact that while most of a student's money is pulled out of public education via vouchers, the public school district where that student resides is still strapped with providing that kid's transportation, books, and any costs arising from those special needs mentioned above. I'll end with some more public scrutiny on education, but let's move on.
The other nail in Giuliani's coffin was the great opportunity he had when a YouTuber asked all the candidates if they believed every word of the bible he held up in his video clip. Giuliani skirted the issue, as did Romney and Hunter (no one else answered) by saying he felt there was a lot allegory and metaphor in the book. He also added that the book contained a lot of wisdom that got him through 9/11 - a point on which I won't disagree, but that brings me to what I feel is the biggest non-issue in any election, except maybe for Pope, and that's religion.
There's simply no place for it, and thus no place for religious-based views on abortion or any other religious (non-presidential) issues in a presidential campaign. Period.
We're electing a man (or maybe a woman) to execute laws made by men, on behalf of a citizenry of men, alive on this earth. That man (or woman) has to sell himself (or herself) on the merits of qualifications for that job, not for his thoughts on the afterlife. In fact, I'm starting to be convinced that a belief in an afterlife should disqualify anyone from being a leader anywhere but in a church. And moderate religious beliefs like Giuliani's are the worst kind.
Yep. That's what I said. Let it sink in for a minute. Go ahead and go back to some old posts where I referred to God... call up the seeming contradiction... It's not seeming, it's a contradiction, although I will hedge a little here and claim that even that God I referred to in previous posts probably wasn't the one you think it is, but that's not the point here.
Religious moderation is what allows tolerance for other religions, which means those religions continue to fly under the radar of rational thought and discussion. Pick one. Let's use Islam for now. Moderate Christians who interpret their faith as tolerant of other faiths help perpetuate the divide between Christians and Muslims. There are a number of problems with this, not the least of which is 9/11... or that the bible allows very little tolerance of other faiths. Four of the ten commandments are about intolerance of other faiths... five if you count keeping the Sabbath holy (after all, it's a pretty specific Sabbath in mind there). Even the new testament calls for stoning heretics to death (and so you'll all have to line up at my door in order to follow Christian beliefs to the letter as a result of this post). Lucky for me, most Christians these days consider themselves moderate and will tolerate my opinions. Which is to say, most Christians are that only in name, not in practice. Those same people often claim that suicide bombers don't really represent the ideals of the faith they claim drove them to their acts. But it's precisely a belief in their faith that allows them to do what they do... because they believe in an afterlife at the expense of those in their current life. In other words, moderates aren't really religious; only fundamentalists are. Fundamentalists are pretty extreme and thus are seen by most moderate members of their own faith as irrational. I'm saying that moderates perpetuate that irrationality and what we need in the next elections is rationality. Back to the real point here, Giuliani, a seemingly rational guy for a Republican, had the chance to run away on this point, and he blew it. Nothing he mentioned until this question was asked had any connection whatsoever to any kind of faith, and yet, when faced with a question about it, rather than pointing out it had little to do with what any of them were talking about thus far tonight, he went with the status quo and lumped himself in with the rest of the candidates (except Paul) who said what they thought the conservative Christian right wanted to hear. Not because of any rational basis for it, unless you count belief rational, but because it polled well.
It's time to get over it. It's time we looked more at experience than religion in a candidate. The time to elect actors with minimal experience and all the right religious answers has come and gone. Sorry Senator Thompson.
Still don't buy my implication that religious faith requires irrational thought and requires the absence of rational discussion of more important actually relevant issues? Consider the British teacher in the Sudan who was arrested for allowing her students to name their class mascot, a teddy bear, Muhammad (peace be unto him)(I'm not making the same "mistakes" she did!)
As part of a lesson on animals, the class adopted the bear as a mascot. Students took turns taking the bear home overnight. They wrote a diary entry addressed to the bear by a name that they chose. Once all the diary entries were done, the teacher surveyed them and chose the most popular choice. The class named the bear and the teacher was arrested. Under the local law, she faces up to a year in prison and/or 40 lashes, from what I've read... FOR ALLOWING HER CLASS TO NAME A BEAR. That's what happens when religion influences the laws of men.
Apparently some parent complaints AFTER the naming of the bear brought attention to the crime. Where were those parents during the weeks of overnight diary entries? Why is it ok that that particular name is the most popular name for male babies in the world but not for a bear? Why was the teacher arrested?
Simple. Two reasons: 1) No rational discussion is permitted when faith enters the conversation. 2) Teachers, worldwide apparently, though I thought ours was alone in this, are at fault when anything goes wrong at any point in anyone's life.
Giuliani lost my support by perpetuating those two simple rules. Dr. Paul gained my support by effectively leaving them out of the conversation when his fellow candidates could not. I'm really starting to think I could vote for this guy... and that there's no way in hell I could vote for any of the other Republican candidates. Once again, none of my favorites will likely end up on a ballot.
I hope, for the sake of my grandchildren, there will one day be a presidential debate where these issues don't factor in. I'm reading a book about Da Vinci right now that puts human understanding into stark perspective. Poor old Leonardo was born at a time when it was believed that everything we ever needed to know had already been discovered. Five hundred years later a vast majority of Americans still operate under this belief. In spite of the gains we've made in physics, chemistry and biology, we remain frighteningly outdated in spiritual and emotional knowledge. Until we come up with a rational way to discuss these issues, we won't rationally discuss anything.
Instead, we'll tiptoe around for fear of offending anyone's religious ideas and we'll watch as religiously motivated violence continues now like it always has. 9-11, the Crusades, Israel-Palestine, India-Pakistan... on it goes until one of two solutions arise. 1) India-Pakistan (or any of the others) erupts into a nuclear apocalypse or 2) Rational discussion replaces the faith-based dance.
I'm pretty sure I'll love my grandchildren if or when I finally have a chance to meet them. I'm sorry for the world I fear we'll leave them. I'm glad I won't be here to see the end they'll inherit. I don't think I could face that.
In the meantime, my kids and I put up our holiday decorations tonight. That's right, we too will celebrate Sol Invictus on December 25! (By now everyone who admits evidence into the discussion knows that Jesus was born in the spring... or January, or November, right?)
At least we can all agree on Santa.
Luth,
Out.
But on to more pressing issues. Tonight's debate cleared some things up for me. Namely, Ron Paul is the only presidential candidate the Republicans could field that I'd even think about voting for. They won't field him, and, so, I won't vote Republican. Glad that's cleared up. I didn't know much about Romney or Hunter and I was curious to learn about them. I did. They're dead to me now.
Giuliani was on my list until tonight. And to his credit, he stayed there for most of the night, until he answered two questions. One was about why blacks and latinos don't vote for Republicans. Giuliani's answer indicated that they should because of what Republicans want to do with education in America. I always knew there was something I didn't like about this guy, and his answer clarified it for me. I agreed with his stance on most issues up to that point. I like reasonable gun laws. I like the fact that he doesn't really see abortion as a presidential issue, but still feels there are circumstances under which it should be legal. I like his focus on the issues at hand - crime when he was mayor, long term investments in infrastructure, and getting things done. I like a lot of things about POLITICAL (not religious) conservativism. He's a pretty good guy among his group.
But when he forced the issue of school vouchers and the non-existent alternatives to public education for the vast majority of Americans, thus pulling even more money out of an already bankrupt public education system, he lost me. This is one issue that not only affects the daily lives of many innocent Americans, but also dramatically affects our future. Public education is the best thing there is for 5-18 year olds in this country. In spite of the whining we hear from Republican candidates about how businesses have had to do more with less and therefore, government should too, both big business and government have gotten richer and richer while public schools, and the Americans who have depended on them have gotten poorer and poorer. Not only have schools still managed to gather intelligent, dedicated, creative and caring professionals at embarrassing wages to teach our kids, there is still simply no better alternative out there. Charter schools routinely close after a few years either because of corruption or because they simply can't provide the services that public schools provide for the money. Private schools exist in such small numbers that they're not even a consideration for even 10% of today's students. Even the handful of minorly successful charter ventures out there exist only for specific audiences by offering one-size-fits-all programs for narrowly targeted groups. There's just nothing better out there for the masses than public schools. And that's not because it's impossible to do, it's because public schools, by and large, are that good. No one can do what public schools do for the money. Teachers already work for embarrassing wages with embarrassing support and the Republican answer is to pull another $5000 per student OUT of that system for vouchers?! To subsidize religious schools or charter programs that haven't kept up?! It's simply not the answer. If, for one minute, America considered putting their money where their mouth is on education in this country, we'd realize that government really is good at some things. Public schools are a good example of that in education just as the Veterans Health Administration is a good example of that in health care. (In spite of CNN's week long attack on VA, it remains the best plan in America... for the record, it was even better before Bush repealed Clinton's Veteran's Healthcare Reform Act forcing VA to bring back the old WWII priority system for who received care - but that's another post) Ask Harvard... ask the NIH... nobody beats VHA health care. When we put some faith, some community involvement, and some money back into public education, no one will beat them. Few do now. Public schools are the living breathing example of doing more with less and all they have to show for it is more and more of the blame when every bit of accountability from parenting to counseling to babysitting is pushed onto them and more and more money is taken away. Never mind the fact that kids with special needs are simply not profitable to teach and so would become impossible to find a place for in the "open education market." Never mind the fact that while most of a student's money is pulled out of public education via vouchers, the public school district where that student resides is still strapped with providing that kid's transportation, books, and any costs arising from those special needs mentioned above. I'll end with some more public scrutiny on education, but let's move on.
The other nail in Giuliani's coffin was the great opportunity he had when a YouTuber asked all the candidates if they believed every word of the bible he held up in his video clip. Giuliani skirted the issue, as did Romney and Hunter (no one else answered) by saying he felt there was a lot allegory and metaphor in the book. He also added that the book contained a lot of wisdom that got him through 9/11 - a point on which I won't disagree, but that brings me to what I feel is the biggest non-issue in any election, except maybe for Pope, and that's religion.
There's simply no place for it, and thus no place for religious-based views on abortion or any other religious (non-presidential) issues in a presidential campaign. Period.
We're electing a man (or maybe a woman) to execute laws made by men, on behalf of a citizenry of men, alive on this earth. That man (or woman) has to sell himself (or herself) on the merits of qualifications for that job, not for his thoughts on the afterlife. In fact, I'm starting to be convinced that a belief in an afterlife should disqualify anyone from being a leader anywhere but in a church. And moderate religious beliefs like Giuliani's are the worst kind.
Yep. That's what I said. Let it sink in for a minute. Go ahead and go back to some old posts where I referred to God... call up the seeming contradiction... It's not seeming, it's a contradiction, although I will hedge a little here and claim that even that God I referred to in previous posts probably wasn't the one you think it is, but that's not the point here.
Religious moderation is what allows tolerance for other religions, which means those religions continue to fly under the radar of rational thought and discussion. Pick one. Let's use Islam for now. Moderate Christians who interpret their faith as tolerant of other faiths help perpetuate the divide between Christians and Muslims. There are a number of problems with this, not the least of which is 9/11... or that the bible allows very little tolerance of other faiths. Four of the ten commandments are about intolerance of other faiths... five if you count keeping the Sabbath holy (after all, it's a pretty specific Sabbath in mind there). Even the new testament calls for stoning heretics to death (and so you'll all have to line up at my door in order to follow Christian beliefs to the letter as a result of this post). Lucky for me, most Christians these days consider themselves moderate and will tolerate my opinions. Which is to say, most Christians are that only in name, not in practice. Those same people often claim that suicide bombers don't really represent the ideals of the faith they claim drove them to their acts. But it's precisely a belief in their faith that allows them to do what they do... because they believe in an afterlife at the expense of those in their current life. In other words, moderates aren't really religious; only fundamentalists are. Fundamentalists are pretty extreme and thus are seen by most moderate members of their own faith as irrational. I'm saying that moderates perpetuate that irrationality and what we need in the next elections is rationality. Back to the real point here, Giuliani, a seemingly rational guy for a Republican, had the chance to run away on this point, and he blew it. Nothing he mentioned until this question was asked had any connection whatsoever to any kind of faith, and yet, when faced with a question about it, rather than pointing out it had little to do with what any of them were talking about thus far tonight, he went with the status quo and lumped himself in with the rest of the candidates (except Paul) who said what they thought the conservative Christian right wanted to hear. Not because of any rational basis for it, unless you count belief rational, but because it polled well.
It's time to get over it. It's time we looked more at experience than religion in a candidate. The time to elect actors with minimal experience and all the right religious answers has come and gone. Sorry Senator Thompson.
Still don't buy my implication that religious faith requires irrational thought and requires the absence of rational discussion of more important actually relevant issues? Consider the British teacher in the Sudan who was arrested for allowing her students to name their class mascot, a teddy bear, Muhammad (peace be unto him)(I'm not making the same "mistakes" she did!)
As part of a lesson on animals, the class adopted the bear as a mascot. Students took turns taking the bear home overnight. They wrote a diary entry addressed to the bear by a name that they chose. Once all the diary entries were done, the teacher surveyed them and chose the most popular choice. The class named the bear and the teacher was arrested. Under the local law, she faces up to a year in prison and/or 40 lashes, from what I've read... FOR ALLOWING HER CLASS TO NAME A BEAR. That's what happens when religion influences the laws of men.
Apparently some parent complaints AFTER the naming of the bear brought attention to the crime. Where were those parents during the weeks of overnight diary entries? Why is it ok that that particular name is the most popular name for male babies in the world but not for a bear? Why was the teacher arrested?
Simple. Two reasons: 1) No rational discussion is permitted when faith enters the conversation. 2) Teachers, worldwide apparently, though I thought ours was alone in this, are at fault when anything goes wrong at any point in anyone's life.
Giuliani lost my support by perpetuating those two simple rules. Dr. Paul gained my support by effectively leaving them out of the conversation when his fellow candidates could not. I'm really starting to think I could vote for this guy... and that there's no way in hell I could vote for any of the other Republican candidates. Once again, none of my favorites will likely end up on a ballot.
I hope, for the sake of my grandchildren, there will one day be a presidential debate where these issues don't factor in. I'm reading a book about Da Vinci right now that puts human understanding into stark perspective. Poor old Leonardo was born at a time when it was believed that everything we ever needed to know had already been discovered. Five hundred years later a vast majority of Americans still operate under this belief. In spite of the gains we've made in physics, chemistry and biology, we remain frighteningly outdated in spiritual and emotional knowledge. Until we come up with a rational way to discuss these issues, we won't rationally discuss anything.
Instead, we'll tiptoe around for fear of offending anyone's religious ideas and we'll watch as religiously motivated violence continues now like it always has. 9-11, the Crusades, Israel-Palestine, India-Pakistan... on it goes until one of two solutions arise. 1) India-Pakistan (or any of the others) erupts into a nuclear apocalypse or 2) Rational discussion replaces the faith-based dance.
I'm pretty sure I'll love my grandchildren if or when I finally have a chance to meet them. I'm sorry for the world I fear we'll leave them. I'm glad I won't be here to see the end they'll inherit. I don't think I could face that.
In the meantime, my kids and I put up our holiday decorations tonight. That's right, we too will celebrate Sol Invictus on December 25! (By now everyone who admits evidence into the discussion knows that Jesus was born in the spring... or January, or November, right?)
At least we can all agree on Santa.
Luth,
Out.
Thursday, November 22, 2007
How Much Is A Billion Dollars?
When referring to the idea that no one seems to care how much money is, in my humble opinion, being wasted in Iraq, I've alluded to the idea that few of us have a concept of what a billion dollars really is. I know I don't. I've only recently wrapped my brain about what a million dollars is, and that, largely because it ain't what it used to be. But I ran across this in the National Guard Enlisted Association newsletter in an article about the Congress's fight over the war spending supplement and thought it might be cool to pass along.
How Much Is A Billion Dollars?
---A billion hours ago, humans were making their first tools in the Stone Age.(of course, if you're a creationist, this one makes no sense)
---A billion minutes ago, it was 104 A.D. and the Chinese first invented paper.
---A billion seconds ago, it was 1975 and the last American troops had pulled out of Vietnam.
---A billion dollars ago, it was only 3 HOURS and 32 MINUTES at the rate our government spends money.
On another note, Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours. I have to go now. If my wife catches me 'blogging while we're supposed to be getting ready to head over the river and through the woods, I'm as cooked as that turkey soon will be.
Luth
Out
How Much Is A Billion Dollars?
---A billion hours ago, humans were making their first tools in the Stone Age.(of course, if you're a creationist, this one makes no sense)
---A billion minutes ago, it was 104 A.D. and the Chinese first invented paper.
---A billion seconds ago, it was 1975 and the last American troops had pulled out of Vietnam.
---A billion dollars ago, it was only 3 HOURS and 32 MINUTES at the rate our government spends money.
On another note, Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours. I have to go now. If my wife catches me 'blogging while we're supposed to be getting ready to head over the river and through the woods, I'm as cooked as that turkey soon will be.
Luth
Out
Thursday, October 25, 2007
Coming Soon
No, I'm serious. I'll get back to this thing eventually. I've been kicking around a bunch of great 'blog ideas including the latest rant on left lane losers, but the two things that have been bugging me the most and that will appear here before 2008 for sure are:
1. Public Healthcare - Why even Republicans will eventually come around
To put it simply, big business will fail if it doesn't offer health plans to get and keep good workers. GM's latest union contracts are proving that even the biggest businesses can no longer afford it. When it becomes a problem for big business, even the Republicans will begin to question why we're the only developed country in the world without public health care. Nevermind the fact that my new employer, Veterans Health Administration, has proven that a government sponsored and administered health care plan can be one of the best systems around. (That's kind of a different topic, but there are some connections)(Oh and another related but different topic has to do with free markets and the lack thereof in health care.)
2. Is there a god? I'm beginning to wonder, but in my quest I've become convinced that organized religion does way more harm than good. (You can't argue with the history!)
Those two topics should put everyone's mind at rest until I get some time to write enough to put you to sleep, eh?
Smell ya later,
Luth.
1. Public Healthcare - Why even Republicans will eventually come around
To put it simply, big business will fail if it doesn't offer health plans to get and keep good workers. GM's latest union contracts are proving that even the biggest businesses can no longer afford it. When it becomes a problem for big business, even the Republicans will begin to question why we're the only developed country in the world without public health care. Nevermind the fact that my new employer, Veterans Health Administration, has proven that a government sponsored and administered health care plan can be one of the best systems around. (That's kind of a different topic, but there are some connections)(Oh and another related but different topic has to do with free markets and the lack thereof in health care.)
2. Is there a god? I'm beginning to wonder, but in my quest I've become convinced that organized religion does way more harm than good. (You can't argue with the history!)
Those two topics should put everyone's mind at rest until I get some time to write enough to put you to sleep, eh?
Smell ya later,
Luth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)